The best of times. NFL29287. Topic

Here a new idea or partially new. The classic Styx song is to blame for this theme title! What was your favorite year? Or favorite player with their career year? Or your top Offensive or defensive team?

pick 1 year and 1 roster spot to claim the rights to. Your roster is filled with only selections from that year. All 23 spots. NO clones.

for your exclusive player or OL or DEF, you have the player exclusively and no other team can pick any year of that player. For the OL or DEF, you get an 11 year bubble to protect them, but must be the year of your theme and the same as the other 22 spots.

Examples: you select 1987. You want the 87 Bears DEF, your bubble just needs to contain the 87 year and the roster all 87 player/unit entries. The bubble could be 77-87 or 87-97 or up-to any 11 year consecutive span including 87.

You select 2018 Drew Brees. All spots are 2018.

70 million. Post your year and claimed player or bubble of a OL or DEF.

one team per owner until half full. A random idea and post here, so ask questions if something isn’t clear.

***Owners may change their exclusive player or unit at anytime up-to the last team being submitted. You must post a switch in the forum in order for it to be official.

***However, the YEAR you claim is FINAL once selected.

Years NOT available:
2018
1997
2024
2011
2006
2004

players/units NOT available:
RB Saquon Barkley
RB Barry Sanders
Ravens OL 2015-25 bubble
QB Aaron Rodgers
QB Peyton Manning
Bills DEF 2000-05 and 07-10.

Also of note with the OL and DEF wrt 11 year bubbles- should it overlap with someone's exclusive year, we will go by who designates FIRST.

Example: If you take 1972 as your year. Then select the 72 Dolphins DEF as your exclusive unit with a bubble of 1970-1980. You block anyone from using a Dolphins DEF from 1970-1980 IF there are no 70s claimed by another owner YET as their year.

However, if someone has already selected 1976, then the Dolphins for just 1976 would be fair game for that owner. The bubble would still protect 70-75 and 77-80 for Dolphins DEF for the other owner. This will make more sense when claims are made official. We will notify everyone when there is an overlap and offer a chance to adjust the bubble or what units are off limits due to pre-existing bubbles.

Owners:
1-seay00: 2018 Ambassadors of Quan. Entered.
2- greenberet: 1997. Scary Barry. Cleared. Entered.
3- nato6869: 2024. SHARKS. Cleared. Entered.
4- milest: 2011.
5- PsychoWarper: 2006. Black Parade. Entered.
6- gyrene: 2004. Unchained. Entered.
10/6/2026 6:01 PM (edited)
I’ll take 2018 as my exclusive year. And Saquan Barkley as my exclusive player.

These selections should serve your team nucleus wrt style and salary—while also removing some great players in 2018 from consideration of another owner. I was purposely looking to take studs and salary bargains away. A lot of great years in 2018 are no longer available. Pick another year!

9/29/2026 5:56 PM
Owners may change their exclusive player or unit at anytime up-to the last team being submitted. You must post a switch in the forum in order for it to be official.

However, the YEAR you claim is FINAL once selected.

I will remain with Saquan Barkley throughout and I’ll post my full roster tomorrow.
9/29/2026 9:52 PM (edited)
Am I right that we wouldn’t really be able to enter our teams until all 24 teams have chosen their year/player? Since the 24th team’s proprietary player could be on anyone’s team up until then and then everyone that was using them would have to go back and redo their roster.
9/29/2026 7:11 PM
Great question. That is what makes this interesting. If someone designates a player/unit that you already rostered (not designated), it will require owners to remove and replace that player or unit. It’s the risk you take when determining your exclusive player/unit. Perhaps, you select a year with many options due to potentially leaving something unprotected.

and it may provide incentive for owners to try different roster styles (eras) and maybe not everyone jumping on 21st century assets (for fear of losing certain desired players/units). I could end up with a decent but not great qb due to the Saquan selection. And I didn’t even look at defense, I just wanted that RB for my entertainment more than anything.

We could have a 7 day limit to enter your roster after you make your claims. I don’t want to make too many rules, let’s allow this to develop naturally.
9/29/2026 7:54 PM (edited)
I’ll post my full roster tomorrow for 2018. Should someone designate a player/unit (in the future) that I rostered other than protected RB Saquan Barkley, then I’ll remove and replace with a different 2018 selection.

Please do not post your rosters here. Feel free to submit them after we create a league number. I will do that tomorrow as well. In the event, we have players/units designated that were on other teams, I’ll sitemail those owners only after posted here.
9/29/2026 8:32 PM
I’ll take 1997 as my exclusive year. And Barry Sanders as my exclusive player.
9/29/2026 11:49 PM
NFL29287 is launched. My full roster is copied here. A very fun build. I couldn't skimp in salary on the kicker, punter, or back up RBs. And the defenses weren't aplenty or elite in my year. But I got Roquan Smith and Khalil Mack as very nice surprises on my DEF! My roster will only be altered if someone designates a player listed here other than RB Saquan Barkley.

Also of note with the OL and DEF wrt 11 year bubbles- should it overlap with someone's exclusive year, we will go by who designates first.

Example: If you take 1972 as your year. Then select the 72 Dolphins DEF as your exclusive unit with a bubble of 1970-1980. You block anyone from using a Dolphins DEF from 1970-1980 IF there are no 70s claimed by another owner yet as their year. We will notify everyone when there is an overlap and offer a chance to adjust the bubble.

However, if someone has already selected 1976, then the Dolphins for just 1976 would be fair game for that owner. The bubble would still protect 70-75 and 77-80 for Dolphins DEF for the other owner. This will make more sense when claims are made official.



Draft Recap
*** Full Season Team ***
Salary Cap: $70,000,000 Available Cash: $5,437
Current Payroll: $69,994,563 Draft Picks Remaining: 0
Selection Status
Roster Status: Valid
Defense: Offensive Line: Special Teams:
QB minimum: RB minimum: WR minimum:
TE minimum: Kicker: Punter:
Additional Players:
Defense
Team Run Pass Sacks Int Drive Red
Zone
Salary
2018 Chicago Bears 59 66 75 86 66 64 $29,653,420
Offensive Line
Team Run Pass Sack Salary
2018 Los Angeles Rams 78 75 58 $4,922,250
Special Teams Unit
Team Kick
Return
Punt
Return
Kick
Defense
Punt
Defense
Salary
2018 Denver Broncos 33 17 59 36 $2,077,000
Quarterbacks (minimum 3)
Name Dur Pass
Stam
Pass
Acc
Int Run
Stam
Run Salary
1. '18 Jared Goff 100 83 77 64 11 24 $8,137,869
2. '18 Brian Hoyer 31 1 14 100 9 1 $325,000
3. '18 Jacoby Brissett 25 2 14 100 7 1 $325,000
Running Backs (minimum 3)
Name Dur Run
Stam
Run Rec
Stam
Rec Salary
1. '18 Saquon Barkley 100 65 65 79 37 $7,039,673
2. '18 LeGarrette Blount 100 40 27 12 32 $1,783,706
3. '18 Stevan Ridley 62 12 28 6 30 $598,293
4. '18 C.J. Prosise 31 1 1 11 35 $360,001
Wide Receivers (minimum 4)
Name Dur Run
Stam
Run Rec
Stam
Rec Salary
1. '18 Marcus Johnson 31 1 1 23 70 $325,000
2. '18 Darius Jennings 100 1 16 13 42 $343,058
3. '18 Tavon Austin 44 4 100 22 72 $325,000
4. '18 Vyncint Smith 44 1 0 14 75 $325,000
5. '18 Tyreek Hill 100 6 96 77 70 $2,513,934
6. '18 Deontay Burnett 31 1 0 38 60 $358,265
7. '18 Cameron Meredith 38 1 0 28 54 $325,000
8. '18 Adam Thielen 100 1 82 92 52 $2,633,463
Tight Ends (minimum 3)
Name Dur Run
Stam
Run Rec
Stam
Rec Salary
1. '18 George Kittle 100 1 100 77 65 $2,427,868
2. '18 Will Dissly 25 1 0 38 79 $329,274
3. '18 O.J. Howard 62 1 0 57 69 $1,145,898
Field Goal Kicker
Name FG
Acc
XP Salary
'18 Dan Bailey 80 97 $2,586,966
Punter
Name Punt Salary
'18 Matt Darr 48 $1,133,625
9/30/2026 3:11 PM (edited)
Thanks to greenberet for getting a team submitted so quickly.

Just 1 edit needed on a deep bench RB. Sitemail sent.

Something that might help everyone’s team build is grabbing a bulk of the bench guys before you get to the starters. Under normal circumstances with an endless inventory, you know those min salary roster items would be there, but there are fewer of them are available at RB, special teams, kicker, and punter for your exclusive year.

An end-in-mind approach to grab the rest of the starters may not leave you as underwhelmed versus having to downgrade starters to make room for the aforementioned more expensive supporting roster items.
10/1/2026 3:56 PM (edited)
greenberet’s roster of Scary Barry (97) is good to go.

Anyone see or try the Create Coach avatar yet. I saved mine. Wonder when it’s viewable and if it’s just on your page or what. Across all games I’d guess. New option on your WIS main page. It’s not instantaneous, so maybe it updates the next game or next day.
10/1/2026 5:33 PM (edited)
2024 RAVENS OL 2015-2025 BUBBLE
10/2/2026 9:56 AM
Amazing selection and bubble placement.

nato’s SHARKS ‘24 roster is entered and cleared.

Find your year and coveted player/unit. Post here and Lock it down!
10/2/2026 12:46 PM
I will take 2011 Aaron Rodgers
10/5/2026 3:15 PM
Years NOT available:
2018
1997
2024
2011

players/units NOT available:
RB Saquon Barkley
RB Barry Sanders
Ravens OL 2015-25 bubble
QB Aaron Rodgers

Get in and secure your year and exclusive player or unit!

10/6/2026 12:01 AM (edited)
So is the bubble only for if you choose a DEF/Line as your protected unit or is it just you in generally get a bubble for your DEF/Line?
10/5/2026 10:52 PM
12 Next ▸
The best of times. NFL29287. Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.