Franchise Draft 3.0 1969-2025 pardon our progress! Topic

Posted by chewy3344 on 10/16/2025 10:04:00 PM (view original):
3 people can pick currently

sjstapleton (7 picks to finish) - Twins, Mets, Rangers, Angels, Red Sox, Giants, Athletics
pick1or2(2) (1 pick to finish) - Pirates
farleyfustle (2 picks to finish) - Orioles, Cardinals

14 users are done : strubrosII, vilefileman, rmarksduke, parking31, chewy3344(2), ermocito(2), ronthegenius, nbl17, YOGI256, pmwksw, ff09, ermocito, rmarksduke(2), pmars2001
14 franchises are done : Reds, Padres, Cubs, White Sox, Yankees, Astros, Royals, Dodgers, Phillies, Nats/Expos, Braves, Cleveland, Tigers, Brewers
Will have these in tomorrow
10/16/2025 11:21 PM
Even if you just do the Twins and or Mets pick, that will allow others to make some picks. You don't have to submit all7 at once.
10/17/2025 12:17 AM
sjstapleton (7 picks to finish) - Twins, Mets, Rangers


Twins C Phil Roof
Mets C Todd Hundley
Rangers SS Kurt Stillwell
10/17/2025 7:16 AM
Angels, Red Sox


Angels P Scot Shields
Red Sox DH Ted Cox
10/17/2025 7:19 AM
A's P Craig Breslow
Giants SS Ehire Adrianza
10/17/2025 7:28 AM
Round 19 - Twins Kevin Jepsen
Round 20 - Mets Ty Wigginton
10/17/2025 7:41 AM
Reminder as you finish...make sure your players are from full/partial seasons, not combined.

Combined means not limited to the team they were selected to represent.

When you search, if you set "Season Type:" to full/partial, you should see only the eligible versions of the players.
10/17/2025 8:51 AM
Spreadsheet is updated as of kentol picks @ 10/17 07:41 AM

I'll be offline most of today, will post updates late tonight.
10/17/2025 9:18 AM
Round 21 - Rangers Keone Kela
Round 22 - Angels Bob McClure
10/17/2025 9:27 AM
Orioles- Fritzie Connolly
Cards-Bill Lyons

were finished(in more than one way)
10/17/2025 10:56 AM
Round 23 - Red Sox Jason Varitek
Round 24 - Giants Matt Duffy
I really enjoyed this draft. There were a few early picks that I regret, but after that everyone I wanted was available when my turn came. Don't know if that's a good sign or not...



10/17/2025 11:41 AM
I loved how quickly this draft progressed, and it really does help making high picks before low picks.

I might start the sign up list for the next run a few days from now, so that it can be slowly building over time. My guess is the 4.0 draft could start mid/late January. I would probably keep a 2nd team list from the beginning but not use any until a designated start date happened.

Eager to hear thoughts here (or backchannel) on what we should tweak. I sense that people like making their 1st picks first - correct? Should we go 25 rounds and have your primary team be picks 1 & 25? Should we try to run more than 2 picks a day (but keeping windows open for seveal hours at least? Change the cap either direction? Have people sign up by striking primary teams they have played and don't want to play again?

I am guessing this league could NOT effectively use the draft feature in WIS (which I have never used, but there is a league that needs 3 more players to use it for the 2025 players .... (THM75898).
10/17/2025 12:03 PM
I've been in several leagues using the live draft utility on WIS and I really like it. Once a player is chosen there he's off the board - clones of players from more than one team would be out. I like having a set window for your picks - and with the live utility you can easily see other player's picks (sorted by position) so you can plan accordingly. With no set time limit for picks I thought this draft would bog down but it has gone fairly smoothly. Your running updates on selections really helped move the draft along. Good job, commishioner...
10/17/2025 1:35 PM
chewy3344
Rd 24 Orioles Dave Ford
10/17/2025 2:08 PM
I really liked starting with the two picks. You get to avoid making a coin flip between a pitcher and a position player (18 owners did the split, 4 double-dipped on pitchers and 2 on batters). I would definitely want to keep that the same. On the days where I didn't get to make a pick I would figure out who I would have drafted with the double picks.

I haven't done the live draft utility, but it sounds like fun (and this draft was a lot of fun, getting up in the middle of the night to see what picks were in, and putting together practice rosters to see if picks would work).

The cap should not go down. It doesn't have to go up, but I won't complain if it went up another $10 million and didn't make a big jump.

If we started with two picks a day from the start and then upped it to three or four towards the end, that could work. I toyed with the idea of have a cap on how many picks you can fall behind without a penalty, but this draft was not a fair judge of that because we were "on the clock," and nobody ever fell behind that. Many of us were able to take advantage of having multiple picks to make when our turn finally came because we knew not to take an OF on pick A because a better one would be available with pick C. At one point I didn't make 2 picks I could have made because I needed to see who gotten taken in the previous round with the C pick, because I wanted the SP with the C pick over the 2nd choice with the A pick. That being said, you don't want that situation to get out of hand, and, again, everybody made their picks on time. Not their fault some of us were 5+ picks ahead.

I can see a rule that you can't repeat a primary team for five seasons, which should be easier to keep track of than a list that lasts for double-digit seasons. I would love to have the Dodgers for my first pick again, but that should not be permitted for x number of seasons.

Having the spread sheet was very helpful, not just because I could do a word search to make sure my picks were clean, but because I could see the picks of the owners in front of me and see that they already had a 2B and wouldn't be picking the one I wanted five picks down the road. I think it would be helpful that when a pick is made that the position is indicated, because there were a couple of picks where I couldn't tell which infield position they were being picked for.

Also, for future spreadsheets for this draft, it might be helpful if the order of the owners was not alphabetical but the order in which we are picking. Then you can see who you are waiting on if chewy is not around next time diligently reminding us of who is up to bat.
10/17/2025 2:30 PM
◂ Prev 1...29|30|31|32|33 Next ▸
Franchise Draft 3.0 1969-2025 pardon our progress! Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.