501 Baseball Books Fans Must Read Before They Die (2013) by Ron Kaplan.
First, the bad. Lots of typos and botched quotes (the author has Yogi Berra saying, “It gets dark early out there”—oof, he stepped all over that classic). And since the 501 entries are by necessity brief, it’s annoying that he wastes precious space telling the reader how many weeks a book spent on the NYT bestseller list or which awards it won (and he does this a lot). A few of the must-read books he seems to not like much, but couches the criticism in “some people think” timidity (except for a Larry King baseball book, not an official entry just one that he mentions in passing, that he outright calls saccharine trash, ha ha). Finally, for some unexplained reason, a bunch of the most famous baseball books ever (Glory of Their Times, Boys of Summer, Bill James Historical Baseball Abstract, etc.) don't have their own entries, even though they're referenced admiringly in discussions on other books. Maybe the author thinks they're so well known they need no promotion, but he doesn't say that.
The good? I was introduced to a ton of baseball books I’ve never heard of, that sound really terrific, and that I’ll be tracking down and reading. Even with the negatives, this is a book worth owning if you're a fan at all of baseball writing.