Most commonly selected players Topic

schwarze
Posts: 42161 (46)
Hall of Famer
1826 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
I will use this thread to post the most commonly selected players in each draft.
8/18/2025 9:41 AM
schwarze
Posts: 42161 (46)
Hall of Famer
1826 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
League #1
.
Player .. Seasons .. Total Salary .. Avg Salary
Delahanty, Ed 10 91,186,991 9,118,699
Lajoie, Nap 9 75,845,750 8,427,306
Hamilton, Billy 8 68,220,749 8,527,594
Wagner, Honus 8 62,034,978 7,754,372
McGraw, John 8 40,466,578 5,058,322
Young, Cy 7 99,061,073 14,151,582
Davis, George 7 42,061,692 6,008,813
Waddell, Rube 6 56,556,481 9,426,080
Brouthers, Dan 6 28,367,925 4,727,988
8/18/2025 9:49 AM
schwarze
Posts: 42161 (46)
Hall of Famer
1826 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
League #2
.
Player .. Seasons .. Total Salary .. Avg Salary
Cobb, Ty 13 122,919,857 9,455,374
Speaker, Tris 11 90,259,725 8,205,430
Johnson, Walter 10 152,495,224 15,249,522
Jackson, Joe 10 58,199,143 5,819,914
Collins, Eddie 8 59,607,284 7,450,911
Wagner, Honus 8 53,287,011 6,660,876
Baker, Frank 7 43,448,713 6,206,959
Lajoie, Nap 7 39,487,475 5,641,068
8/18/2025 9:53 AM
schwarze
Posts: 42161 (46)
Hall of Famer
1826 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
League #3
.
Player .. Seasons .. Total Salary .. Avg Salary
Ruth, Babe 12 169,059,007 14,088,251
Hornsby, Rogers 11 111,462,023 10,132,911
Frisch, Frankie 8 54,760,899 6,845,112
Gehrig, Lou 7 74,417,072 10,631,010
Simmons, Al 7 59,194,829 8,456,404
Grove, Lefty 6 54,644,024 9,107,337
Vance, Dazzy 6 53,755,576 8,959,263
Foxx, Jimmie 6 52,288,235 8,714,706
Speaker, Tris 6 51,406,665 8,567,778
Heilmann, Harry 6 44,441,291 7,406,882
Collins, Eddie 6 37,813,842 6,302,307
Cochrane, Mickey 6 36,654,851 6,109,142
8/18/2025 9:56 AM
schwarze
Posts: 42161 (46)
Hall of Famer
1826 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
League #4
.
Player .. Seasons .. Total Salary .. Avg Salary
Vaughan, Arky 9 61,130,025 6,792,225
DiMaggio, Joe 7 59,787,249 8,541,036
Greenberg, Hank 7 50,499,932 7,214,276
Gehringer, Charlie 7 50,166,640 7,166,663
Ott, Mel 7 48,103,865 6,871,981
Mize, Johnny 7 47,182,526 6,740,361
Foxx, Jimmie 6 52,625,788 8,770,965
Dickey, Bill 6 33,036,530 5,506,088
Appling, Luke 6 32,461,839 5,410,307
8/18/2025 9:59 AM
schwarze
Posts: 42161 (46)
Hall of Famer
1826 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
League #5
.
Player .. Seasons .. Total Salary .. Avg Salary
Williams, Ted 12 98,338,815 8,194,901
Musial, Stan 11 96,375,742 8,761,431
Mantle, Mickey 7 71,106,558 10,158,080
Mays, Willie 6 55,858,638 9,309,773
Snider, Duke 6 49,699,271 8,283,212
Ashburn, Richie 6 46,916,905 7,819,484
Robinson, Jackie 6 39,830,435 6,638,406
Berra, Yogi 6 34,554,443 5,759,074

8/23/2025 1:36 PM
schwarze
Posts: 42161 (46)
Hall of Famer
1826 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
League #6
.
Player .. Seasons .. Total Salary .. Avg Salary
Aaron, Hank 9 67,548,970 7,505,441
Robinson, Frank 9 60,870,554 6,763,395
Wilhelm, Hoyt 8 30,836,238 3,854,530
Mays, Willie 7 59,501,624 8,500,232
Mantle, Mickey 6 38,428,071 6,404,679
9/3/2025 10:10 AM
schwarze
Posts: 42161 (46)
Hall of Famer
1826 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
Since we're halfway through round 1, I thought I'd post some other stats...
9/4/2025 6:37 PM
schwarze
Posts: 42161 (46)
Hall of Famer
1826 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
Salary (in millions)
.
Owner___________ Lg01____ Lg02____ Lg03____ Lg04____ Lg05____ Lg06____ Total
njbigwig 199.6 127.6 159.6 169.1 136.8 159.7 158.7
mllama54 170.4 162.8 138.0 150.0 154.9 154.0 155.0
pedrocerrano 206.4 130.8 147.4 145.5 146.0 133.7 151.6
kstober 135.6 139.5 142.5 145.5 163.5 156.0 147.1
DarthDurron 169.9 170.5 138.6 129.3 128.1 145.4 146.9
footballmm11 146.8 162.4 166.3 145.5 129.8 127.5 146.4
schwarze 134.3 150.6 173.4 124.9 144.4 137.5 144.2
calhoop 150.2 156.2 142.3 147.2 126.6 140.1 143.8
Jtpsops 152.5 128.0 160.9 132.6 139.4 139.3 142.1
bigsteve12 137.4 138.4 141.1 137.6 149.3 139.2 140.5
chewy3344 113.6 125.3 179.9 127.3 127.5 139.3 135.5
3dayrotation 134.5 129.0 135.7 135.5 149.9 125.6 135.0
thejuice6 131.2 128.1 163.6 122.6 128.0 123.7 132.9
eblankenstei 132.6 128.2 135.3 129.9 128.1 119.4 128.9
nocomm999 128.9 125.5 142.3 122.5 121.3 125.1 127.6
ronthegenius 119.9 138.6 138.1 127.3 116.5 122.0 127.1
.
Average 147.7 140.1 150.3 137.0 136.9 136.7 141.5
9/4/2025 6:37 PM
schwarze
Posts: 42161 (46)
Hall of Famer
1826 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
Percent of Average...
.
Owner___________ Lg01____ Lg02____ Lg03____ Lg04____ Lg05____ Lg06____ Total
njbigwig 135% 91% 106% 123% 100% 117% 112%
mllama54 115% 116% 92% 110% 113% 113% 110%
pedrocerrano 140% 93% 98% 106% 107% 98% 107%
kstober 92% 100% 95% 106% 119% 114% 104%
DarthDurron 115% 122% 92% 94% 94% 106% 104%
footballmm11 99% 116% 111% 106% 95% 93% 103%
schwarze 91% 107% 115% 91% 106% 101% 102%
calhoop 102% 111% 95% 107% 93% 102% 102%
Jtpsops 103% 91% 107% 97% 102% 102% 100%
bigsteve12 93% 99% 94% 100% 109% 102% 99%
chewy3344 77% 89% 120% 93% 93% 102% 96%
3dayrotation 91% 92% 90% 99% 109% 92% 95%
thejuice6 89% 91% 109% 89% 94% 90% 94%
eblankenstei 90% 92% 90% 95% 94% 87% 91%
nocomm999 87% 90% 95% 89% 89% 91% 90%
ronthegenius 81% 99% 92% 93% 85% 89% 90%
9/4/2025 6:38 PM
schwarze
Posts: 42161 (46)
Hall of Famer
1826 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
Divisions
.
Owner___________ Lg01____ Lg02____ Lg03____ Lg04____ Lg05____ Lg06____
njbigwig NLE ALW NLW NLE NLW NLE
mllama54 NLE NLE ALW NLE NLE NLE
pedrocerrano NLE ALE NLW NLW NLW ALE
kstober ALE NLW NLW NLW NLE NLE
DarthDurron NLE NLE ALE ALE ALE NLE
footballmm11 NLW NLE NLE NLE ALE ALE
schwarze ALE NLW NLE ALW NLW ALE
calhoop NLW NLE ALE NLE ALW NLW
Jtpsops NLW ALW NLW ALE NLW NLW
bigsteve12 NLW NLW ALE NLW NLE NLW
chewy3344 ALW ALW NLE ALW ALW NLW
3dayrotation ALE ALE ALW NLW NLE ALE
thejuice6 ALW ALE NLE ALW ALE ALW
eblankenstei ALE ALE ALW ALE ALE ALW
nocomm999 ALW ALW ALE ALW ALW ALW
ronthegenius ALW NLW ALW ALE ALW ALW
9/4/2025 6:53 PM
footballmm11
Posts: 4624 (4)
Hall of Famer
525 5 11
Veteran
this is cool
9/5/2025 6:56 PM
Most commonly selected players Topic
△Top△Bottom

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.