We have finished season 2 of the Hall of Pretty Good League and are starting signups for season 3. The rules are pretty simple:
- All players must have a bWAR lower than 38.6 (per Baseball Reference)
- No MVPs or Cy Young award winners
- Can't be a Hall of Famer
- Cannot be in the top 15 all-time in saves
- Must be officially retired or do not have an official WIS season in three years
- 1930- present
$110 mil salary cap, no WWW, clones, trades or AAA. No DH. Designed to celebrate the players with great seasons/good careers. Modeled after the
MLB Hall of Pretty Good Twitter/Instagram account.
WAR Database:
https://www.baseball-reference.com/leaders/WAR_career.shtml
Every year, the league's Cy Young, MVP and Fireman Award winners are blacklisted (they graduate from the Hall of Pretty Good and into the Hall of Very Good lol). So far, these are the blacklisted players:
'99 Shawn Green
'45 Tommy Holmes
'81 Dave Righetti
'85 John Tudor
'95 Norm Charleton
'08 Joe Nathan
'41 Pete Reiser
'30 Ed Morgan
'43 Spud Chandler
'63 Dick Ellsworth
'08 Joakim Soria
'92 Roberto Hernandez
Sign up now in the forums. Standard 24 team league, returning players will have a week's priority before we open up to new owners. If you are new, you can still secure your place now. I will have a league number out in the coming few days.
1)
giannivanaco
2)
thebubbaq
3)
TBill7
4)
Rattlers
5)
eastvanmungo
6)
trd3
7)
lenbo1212
8)
spinaldog
9)
waynemiller
10)
midknight
11)
mensu1954
12)
markthelow
13)
mjoyce103
14)
burningcouch
15)
boclaird
16) cleansox
5/27/2026 12:38 AM (edited)