| Lineup | Gettysburg | PG - William Menges (fresh) 2 pts. 3 ast. SG - Cody Schumacher (fresh) 15 pts. SF - Robert Pierce (fresh) PF - James Cain (fresh) 6 pts. 3 reb. C - Christopher Skates (fresh) 3 pts. 4 reb. 2 stl. | |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Kevin Harris (fresh) SG - Manuel Head (fresh) 2 ast. SF - Brian Shelton (fresh) PF - Justin Gottlieb (fresh) 4 reb. C - Huey Garay (fresh) 13 pts. 5 reb. 2 stl. | |
| 20:00 | Gettysburg | Robert Pierce inbounds the ball | 36-30 |
| Game Plan | Gettysburg | Gettysburg is playing a flex offense and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (0) | |
| 19:39 | Gettysburg | James Cain's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 36-30 |
| 19:14 | John Jay | Huey Garay is hacked by Christopher Skates - foul #3 on Christopher Skates, team foul #1 | 36-30 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | Greg Vice (C) Christopher Skates | |
| Subs | John Jay | | |
| 19:06 | John Jay | Manuel Head throws a bad pass out of bounds | 36-30 |
| 18:48 | Gettysburg | Robert Pierce clanks a jumper from the free throw line | 36-30 |
| 18:47 | John Jay | Huey Garay gets the rebound | 36-30 |
| 18:41 | John Jay | Manuel Head throws a bad pass out of bounds | 36-30 |
| 18:27 | Gettysburg | William Menges scores on a fadeaway jumper from the right side on a great pass from Cody Schumacher | 38-30 |
| 18:17 | John Jay | Huey Garay misses badly on a jump hook in the lane but he's fouled by Greg Vice - foul #1 on Greg Vice, team foul #2 | 38-30 |
| 18:17 | John Jay | Huey Garay misses the 1st free throw | 38-30 |
| 18:17 | John Jay | Huey Garay makes the 2nd free throw | 38-31 |
| 18:04 | Gettysburg | James Cain hits the front of the rim on the jumper in the paint but the foul's on Huey Garay - foul #3 on Huey Garay, team foul #1 | 38-31 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | | |
| Subs | John Jay | Phillip Rasmussen (C) Huey Garay | |
| 18:04 | Gettysburg | James Cain misses the 1st free throw | 38-31 |
| 18:04 | Gettysburg | James Cain makes the 2nd free throw | 39-31 |
| 17:38 | John Jay | Justin Gottlieb knocks in the 3pt attempt from the right wing on a great pass from Manuel Head | 39-34 |
| 17:30 | Gettysburg | Cody Schumacher can't connect on a 3pt attempt from the left corner | 39-34 |
| 17:29 | John Jay | Brian Shelton snags the defensive board | 39-34 |
| 17:19 | John Jay | Kevin Harris misses badly on a floater from the right side but the foul's on Robert Pierce - foul #1 on Robert Pierce, team foul #3 | 39-34 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | Brad Lax (PG), Robert Zolinas (SG), Joseph Tepper (SF) William Menges, Cody Schumacher, Robert Pierce | |
| Subs | John Jay | Dean Sharper (SG), John Merkle (SF) Manuel Head, Brian Shelton | |
| 17:19 | John Jay | Kevin Harris misses the 1st free throw | 39-34 |
| 17:19 | John Jay | Kevin Harris misses the 2nd free throw | 39-34 |
| 17:19 | John Jay | The offensive rebound goes to Phillip Rasmussen | 39-34 |
| 17:12 | John Jay | Dean Sharper connects on the 3 from straight away | 39-37 |
| 16:56 | Gettysburg | James Cain travels with the ball | 39-37 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | Paul Olson (C) James Cain | |
| Subs | John Jay | Kevin Battaglia (PG), Nicholas Murphy (PF) Kevin Harris, Justin Gottlieb | |
| 16:27 | John Jay | Nicholas Murphy misses the fadeaway from the right side | 39-37 |
| 16:25 | Gettysburg | Greg Vice grabs the board | 39-37 |
| 16:10 | Gettysburg | Joseph Tepper misses short on a 3pt attempt from the left wing | 39-37 |
| 16:09 | Gettysburg | Greg Vice tips it but misses | 39-37 |
| 16:08 | John Jay | Phillip Rasmussen grabs the defensive rebound | 39-37 |
| 15:58 | John Jay | John Merkle throws a bad pass out of bounds | 39-37 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | William Menges (PG), Robert Pierce (SF), James Cain (PF), Christopher Skates (C) Brad Lax, Joseph Tepper, Greg Vice, Paul Olson | |
| Subs | John Jay | Dustin Floyd (PG), Justin Gottlieb (PF), Huey Garay (C) Kevin Battaglia, Nicholas Murphy, Phillip Rasmussen | |
| Lineup | Gettysburg | PG - William Menges (fresh) 4 pts. 3 ast. SG - Robert Zolinas (fresh) 2 pts. SF - Robert Pierce (fresh) PF - James Cain (fresh) 7 pts. 3 reb. C - Christopher Skates (fresh) 3 pts. 4 reb. 2 stl. 3 pf. | |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Dustin Floyd (fresh) 8 pts. 2 ast. 3 pf. SG - Dean Sharper (fresh) 5 pts. SF - John Merkle (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. PF - Justin Gottlieb (fresh) 3 pts. 4 reb. C - Huey Garay (fresh) 14 pts. 6 reb. 2 stl. 3 pf. | |
| 15:41 | Gettysburg | Christopher Skates is hacked by Huey Garay - foul #4 on Huey Garay, team foul #2 | 39-37 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | Cody Schumacher (SG) Robert Zolinas | |
| Subs | John Jay | Kevin Harris (SG), Nicholas Murphy (C) Dean Sharper, Huey Garay | |
| 15:34 | Gettysburg | James Cain connects on the jumper from the free throw line on a nice dish by Cody Schumacher | 41-37 |
| 15:23 | John Jay | Christopher Skates swats the short shot by Dustin Floyd | 41-37 |
| 15:22 | Gettysburg | Christopher Skates grabs the board | 41-37 |
| 15:09 | Gettysburg | John Merkle steals it from Cody Schumacher | 41-37 |
| 14:52 | John Jay | Justin Gottlieb buries a 3 from the left corner set up by John Merkle | 41-40 |
| 14:34 | Gettysburg | Robert Pierce buries a floater from the right side | 43-40 |
| 14:28 | John Jay | Dustin Floyd drills a shot from the right side set up by Justin Gottlieb | 43-42 |
| 14:13 | Gettysburg | Cody Schumacher throws a bad pass out of bounds | 43-42 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | Brad Lax (PG), Robert Zolinas (SG), Joseph Tepper (SF), Greg Vice (PF) William Menges, Cody Schumacher, Robert Pierce, James Cain | |
| Subs | John Jay | Manuel Head (SG), Brian Shelton (SF), Phillip Rasmussen (C) Kevin Harris, John Merkle, Nicholas Murphy | |
| 13:56 | John Jay | Phillip Rasmussen drills a jump hook in the paint and he's fouled by Christopher Skates - foul #4 on Christopher Skates, team foul #4 | 43-44 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | Paul Olson (C) Christopher Skates | |
| Subs | John Jay | | |
| 13:56 | John Jay | Phillip Rasmussen misses the free throw | 43-44 |
| 13:56 | John Jay | Brian Shelton snags the offensive board | 43-44 |
| 13:45 | John Jay | Justin Gottlieb slams it home set up by Manuel Head | 43-46 |
| 13:34 | Gettysburg | Joseph Tepper misses short on a 3pt jumper from the left wing | 43-46 |
| 13:33 | Gettysburg | Paul Olson pulls down the offensive rebound | 43-46 |
| 13:23 | Gettysburg | Robert Zolinas misses long on a jumper in the lane but he's hacked by Manuel Head - foul #1 on Manuel Head, team foul #3 | 43-46 |
| 13:23 | Gettysburg | Robert Zolinas makes the 1st free throw | 44-46 |
| 13:23 | Gettysburg | Robert Zolinas makes the 2nd free throw | 45-46 |
| 13:15 | John Jay | Phillip Rasmussen comes up short on the 3pt attempt from the left wing | 45-46 |
| 13:13 | Gettysburg | Paul Olson grabs the defensive rebound | 45-46 |
| 12:53 | Gettysburg | Greg Vice buries a turnaround from the baseline | 47-46 |
| 12:42 | John Jay | Phillip Rasmussen clanks a 3pt jumper from the right wing | 47-46 |
| 12:40 | Gettysburg | Joseph Tepper snags the defensive board | 47-46 |
| 12:21 | Gettysburg | Brad Lax buries a pull-up jumper from just outside the lane set up by Robert Zolinas | 49-46 |
| 12:03 | John Jay | Justin Gottlieb misses short on a runner from the baseline but he's fouled by Greg Vice - foul #2 on Greg Vice, team foul #5 | 49-46 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | William Menges (PG), Cody Schumacher (SG), Robert Pierce (SF), James Cain (PF) Brad Lax, Robert Zolinas, Joseph Tepper, Greg Vice | |
| Subs | John Jay | Kevin Harris (PG), Dean Sharper (SG), John Merkle (SF), Nicholas Murphy (C) Dustin Floyd, Manuel Head, Brian Shelton, Phillip Rasmussen | |
| 12:03 | John Jay | Justin Gottlieb makes the 1st free throw | 49-47 |
| 12:03 | John Jay | Justin Gottlieb misses the 2nd free throw | 49-47 |
| 12:03 | Gettysburg | James Cain grabs the defensive rebound | 49-47 |
| Lineup | Gettysburg | PG - William Menges (fresh) 4 pts. 3 ast. SG - Cody Schumacher (fresh) 15 pts. 2 ast. SF - Robert Pierce (fresh) 2 pts. PF - James Cain (fresh) 9 pts. 4 reb. C - Paul Olson (fresh) 4 reb. | |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Kevin Harris (fresh) SG - Dean Sharper (fresh) 5 pts. SF - John Merkle (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. PF - Justin Gottlieb (fairly fresh) 9 pts. 4 reb. C - Nicholas Murphy (fresh) 3 pts. 3 reb. | |
| 11:47 | Gettysburg | Justin Gottlieb steals the ball from Robert Pierce | 49-47 |
| 11:31 | John Jay | Nicholas Murphy makes the floater near the basket | 49-49 |
| 11:18 | Gettysburg | Cody Schumacher can't connect on a jumpshot from the right wing | 49-49 |
| 11:17 | Gettysburg | James Cain snags the offensive board | 49-49 |
| 11:01 | Gettysburg | James Cain connects on the shot from close range on a great pass from William Menges | 51-49 |
| 10:43 | John Jay | John Merkle lays it up and in on a nice dish by Nicholas Murphy and he's fouled by Robert Pierce - foul #2 on Robert Pierce, team foul #6 | 51-51 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | Greg Vice (C) Paul Olson | |
| Subs | John Jay | Brian Shelton (SF) Justin Gottlieb | |
| 10:43 | John Jay | John Merkle makes the free throw | 51-52 |
| 10:18 | Gettysburg | Cody Schumacher comes up short on the fadeaway jumper from just outside the lane | 51-52 |
| 10:16 | John Jay | Kevin Harris pulls down the rebound | 51-52 |
| 10:03 | John Jay | John Merkle misses badly on a turnaround in the lane | 51-52 |
| 10:02 | John Jay | Brian Shelton grabs the offensive board | 51-52 |
| 09:50 | John Jay | Brian Shelton buries a floater from the left side on a great pass from Kevin Harris | 51-54 |
| 09:29 | Gettysburg | Brian Shelton steps in front of the Greg Vice pass | 51-54 |
| 09:05 | John Jay | Brian Shelton is fouled on the floor by James Cain - foul #1 on James Cain, team foul #7 | 51-54 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | Brad Lax (PG), Robert Zolinas (SG), Joseph Tepper (SF), Richard Ditch (C) William Menges, Cody Schumacher, Robert Pierce, Greg Vice | |
| Subs | John Jay | Dustin Floyd (PG), Manuel Head (SG), Justin Gottlieb (PF), Phillip Rasmussen (C) Kevin Harris, Dean Sharper, Nicholas Murphy, John Merkle | |
| 09:05 | John Jay | Brian Shelton makes the 1st free throw | 51-55 |
| 09:05 | John Jay | Brian Shelton misses the 2nd free throw | 51-55 |
| 09:05 | Gettysburg | Robert Zolinas grabs the board | 51-55 |
| 08:51 | Gettysburg | Joseph Tepper's fadeaway is rejected by Justin Gottlieb | 51-55 |
| 08:50 | John Jay | Phillip Rasmussen grabs the board | 51-55 |
| 08:43 | John Jay | Brian Shelton's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 51-55 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | Paul Olson (PF) James Cain | |
| Subs | John Jay | Don Stanley (SF) Brian Shelton | |
| 08:32 | Gettysburg | Joseph Tepper can't finish the layup | 51-55 |
| 08:30 | John Jay | Justin Gottlieb gets the rebound | 51-55 |
| 08:09 | John Jay | Justin Gottlieb makes the jump hook from the baseline | 51-57 |
| 07:52 | Gettysburg | Joseph Tepper can't connect on a jumper from the left side | 51-57 |
| 07:50 | John Jay | Phillip Rasmussen pulls down the rebound | 51-57 |
| Lineup | Gettysburg | PG - Brad Lax (fresh) 2 pts. 2 ast. SG - Robert Zolinas (fresh) 4 pts. 1 ast. SF - Joseph Tepper (fresh) 8 pts. PF - Paul Olson (fresh) 4 reb. C - Richard Ditch (fresh) | |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Dustin Floyd (fresh) 10 pts. 2 ast. 3 pf. SG - Manuel Head (fresh) 4 ast. SF - Don Stanley (fresh) PF - Justin Gottlieb (fairly fresh) 11 pts. 5 reb. C - Phillip Rasmussen (fresh) 4 pts. 5 reb. | |
| 07:45 | John Jay | Manuel Head scores on a 3pt shot from straight away set up by Dustin Floyd | 51-60 |
| 07:26 | Gettysburg | Paul Olson can't connect on a pull-up jumper from the right side | 51-60 |
| 07:25 | John Jay | The rebound goes to Justin Gottlieb | 51-60 |
| 07:08 | John Jay | Don Stanley buries a jump hook from the right block on a great pass from Dustin Floyd | 51-62 |
| 06:55 | Gettysburg | Richard Ditch can't connect on a jumper from the right wing but the foul's on Phillip Rasmussen - foul #1 on Phillip Rasmussen, team foul #4 | 51-62 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | William Menges (PG), Cody Schumacher (SG), James Cain (PF), Christopher Skates (C) Brad Lax, Robert Zolinas, Joseph Tepper, Paul Olson | |
| Subs | John Jay | Kevin Harris (SG), John Merkle (SF), Nicholas Murphy (PF), Huey Garay (C) Manuel Head, Don Stanley, Justin Gottlieb, Phillip Rasmussen | |
| 06:55 | Gettysburg | Richard Ditch makes the 1st free throw | 52-62 |
| 06:55 | Gettysburg | Richard Ditch makes the 2nd free throw | 53-62 |
| 06:37 | John Jay | Dustin Floyd misses the 3pt shot from the left corner | 53-62 |
| 06:35 | John Jay | Huey Garay hits the follow up shot | 53-64 |
| 06:28 | Gettysburg | Cody Schumacher clanks a jumper from the left wing | 53-64 |
| 06:27 | John Jay | Nicholas Murphy snags the defensive board | 53-64 |
| 06:06 | John Jay | Dustin Floyd misses long on a 3 from the right wing | 53-64 |
| 06:05 | Gettysburg | Cody Schumacher gets the rebound | 53-64 |
| 05:46 | Gettysburg | Cody Schumacher can't connect on a fadeaway from the free throw line | 53-64 |
| 05:44 | Gettysburg | Cody Schumacher tips it in | 55-64 |
| 05:32 | John Jay | Kevin Harris buries a runner in the paint set up by Dustin Floyd | 55-66 |
| 05:12 | Gettysburg | Cody Schumacher misses badly on a 3 from the right corner | 55-66 |
| 05:11 | John Jay | Huey Garay gets the rebound | 55-66 |
| 04:46 | John Jay | William Menges steals the ball from Dustin Floyd | 55-66 |
| 04:43 | Gettysburg | Richard Ditch hits the finger roll set up by William Menges | 57-66 |
| 04:29 | John Jay | Huey Garay hits a turnaround from the baseline on a nice dish by Dustin Floyd | 57-68 |
| 04:10 | Gettysburg | Richard Ditch misses the 3 from the right corner | 57-68 |
| 04:09 | John Jay | Huey Garay grabs the defensive rebound | 57-68 |
| 04:09 | John Jay | John Jay calls a full timeout (2 :30 3 full remaining) | 57-68 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | Robert Zolinas (SG), Robert Pierce (SF) Cody Schumacher, Richard Ditch | |
| Subs | John Jay | Manuel Head (SG), Brian Shelton (SF), Justin Gottlieb (PF) Dustin Floyd, John Merkle, Nicholas Murphy | |
| 03:46 | John Jay | Huey Garay hits the front of the rim on the fadeaway jumper from the right side but he's fouled by William Menges - foul #1 on William Menges, team foul #8 | 57-68 |
| 03:46 | John Jay | Huey Garay makes the 1st free throw | 57-69 |
| 03:46 | John Jay | Huey Garay makes the 2nd free throw | 57-70 |
| Lineup | Gettysburg | PG - William Menges (fresh) 4 pts. 5 ast. SG - Robert Zolinas (fresh) 4 pts. 1 ast. SF - Robert Pierce (fresh) 2 pts. PF - James Cain (fresh) 11 pts. 5 reb. C - Christopher Skates (fresh) 3 pts. 5 reb. 2 stl. 4 pf. | |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Kevin Harris (fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SG - Manuel Head (fresh) 3 pts. 4 ast. SF - Brian Shelton (fresh) 3 pts. 4 reb. PF - Justin Gottlieb (fresh) 11 pts. 6 reb. C - Huey Garay (fresh) 20 pts. 9 reb. 2 stl. 4 pf. | |
| Game Plan | Gettysburg | Gettysburg is playing a flex offense (uptempo) and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (+1) | |
| 03:31 | Gettysburg | Huey Garay blocks the short jumper by Robert Pierce | 57-70 |
| 03:29 | John Jay | Justin Gottlieb snags the defensive board | 57-70 |
| Game Plan | Gettysburg | Gettysburg is playing a flex offense (uptempo) and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a triangle offense (slowdown) and a man to man (+1) | |
| 03:14 | John Jay | Justin Gottlieb's pass is intercepted by James Cain | 57-70 |
| 03:05 | Gettysburg | Robert Zolinas travels with the ball | 57-70 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | Joseph Tepper (SG) William Menges | |
| Subs | John Jay | Dustin Floyd (PG), Phillip Rasmussen (C) Kevin Harris, Huey Garay | |
| 02:41 | John Jay | Dustin Floyd hits the front of the rim on the 3 pointer from the right wing | 57-70 |
| 02:40 | Gettysburg | The rebound goes to Christopher Skates | 57-70 |
| 02:26 | Gettysburg | Joseph Tepper clanks a 3pt jumper from the right corner | 57-70 |
| 02:25 | John Jay | Justin Gottlieb grabs the defensive rebound | 57-70 |
| 01:57 | John Jay | Brian Shelton is hacked by Robert Pierce - foul #3 on Robert Pierce, team foul #9 | 57-70 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | Brad Lax (PG), Greg Vice (PF), Paul Olson (C) Robert Pierce, James Cain, Christopher Skates | |
| Subs | John Jay | Kevin Harris (PG), Dean Sharper (SG), Nicholas Murphy (PF) Dustin Floyd, Manuel Head, Justin Gottlieb | |
| 01:57 | John Jay | Brian Shelton makes the 1st free throw | 57-71 |
| 01:57 | John Jay | Brian Shelton makes the 2nd free throw | 57-72 |
| 01:45 | Gettysburg | Robert Zolinas misses badly on a 3 pointer from the right corner | 57-72 |
| 01:43 | John Jay | Phillip Rasmussen gets the rebound | 57-72 |
| 01:23 | John Jay | Kevin Harris is fouled on the floor by Brad Lax - foul #1 on Brad Lax, team foul #10 | 57-72 |
| Subs | Gettysburg | | |
| Subs | John Jay | John Merkle (SF) Brian Shelton | |
| 01:23 | John Jay | Kevin Harris makes the 1st free throw | 57-73 |
| 01:23 | John Jay | Kevin Harris misses the 2nd free throw | 57-73 |
| 01:23 | Gettysburg | Greg Vice grabs the board | 57-73 |
| 01:08 | Gettysburg | Robert Zolinas knocks in the floater from the right side | 59-73 |
| 00:58 | John Jay | John Merkle is hacked by Robert Zolinas - foul #2 on Robert Zolinas, team foul #11 | 59-73 |
| 00:58 | John Jay | John Merkle makes the 1st free throw | 59-74 |
| 00:58 | John Jay | John Merkle misses the 2nd free throw | 59-74 |
| 00:58 | John Jay | The offensive rebound goes to Nicholas Murphy | 59-74 |
| Game Plan | Gettysburg | Gettysburg is playing a flex offense (uptempo) and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (+1) | |
| 00:35 | John Jay | Kevin Harris knocks in the shot from the right block set up by Dean Sharper | 59-76 |
| Game Plan | Gettysburg | Gettysburg is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (+1) | |
| 00:31 | Gettysburg | Robert Zolinas clanks a 3pt jumper from the left corner | 59-76 |
| 00:29 | John Jay | Phillip Rasmussen grabs the defensive rebound | 59-76 |
| 00:00 | John Jay | Kevin Harris runs out the clock | 59-76 |