| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Richard Johnson (fresh) 8 pts. 2 ast. SG - David Heiman (fresh) SF - Joshua Tillett (fresh) 4 pts. 2 reb. PF - Steven Marion (fresh) 7 pts. 3 reb. C - Houston Williams (fresh) 2 pts. 4 reb. | |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Robert Hepner (fresh) 5 pts. SG - Brian Selden (fresh) 4 ast. SF - Robert Sellers (fresh) 7 pts. 2 reb. PF - Paul Dell (fresh) C - Milton Courville (fresh) 6 pts. 2 reb. | |
| 20:00 | John Jay | Joshua Tillett inbounds the ball | 30-39 |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (+2) | |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a flex offense and a man to man (-1) | |
| 19:46 | John Jay | Joshua Tillett comes up short on the 3 pointer from the right wing | 30-39 |
| 19:44 | Muskingum | The rebound goes to Robert Sellers | 30-39 |
| 19:38 | Muskingum | Brian Selden comes up short on the fadeaway jumper from the free throw line but the foul's on David Heiman - foul #3 on David Heiman, team foul #1 | 30-39 |
| Subs | John Jay | Jerry Goodwin (SG) David Heiman | |
| Subs | Muskingum | | |
| 19:38 | Muskingum | Brian Selden makes the 1st free throw | 30-40 |
| 19:38 | Muskingum | Brian Selden makes the 2nd free throw | 30-41 |
| 19:21 | John Jay | Houston Williams misses long on a jumper from the baseline but the foul's on Milton Courville - foul #2 on Milton Courville, team foul #1 | 30-41 |
| 19:21 | John Jay | Houston Williams misses the 1st free throw | 30-41 |
| 19:21 | John Jay | Houston Williams makes the 2nd free throw | 31-41 |
| 19:08 | Muskingum | Robert Hepner loses the dribble to Steven Marion | 31-41 |
| 18:49 | John Jay | Richard Johnson is hacked by Paul Dell - foul #1 on Paul Dell, team foul #2 | 31-41 |
| 18:36 | John Jay | Richard Johnson scores on a 3pt attempt from straight away set up by Joshua Tillett | 34-41 |
| 18:30 | Muskingum | Brian Selden hits a jumpshot from the left wing on a nice dish by Milton Courville | 34-43 |
| 18:21 | John Jay | Joshua Tillett can't connect on a 3pt attempt from the right corner | 34-43 |
| 18:19 | John Jay | Houston Williams pulls down the offensive rebound | 34-43 |
| 18:09 | John Jay | Richard Johnson can't connect on a 3 from the right corner | 34-43 |
| 18:07 | Muskingum | Paul Dell grabs the defensive rebound | 34-43 |
| 17:49 | Muskingum | Robert Hepner clanks a 3pt shot from the left corner | 34-43 |
| 17:47 | John Jay | Houston Williams snags the defensive board | 34-43 |
| 17:41 | John Jay | Houston Williams double dribbles | 34-43 |
| Subs | John Jay | Alvin Neace (C) Houston Williams | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Thomas Bateman (PF), William Brunell (C) Paul Dell, Milton Courville | |
| 17:19 | Muskingum | Thomas Bateman hits a jumper from the baseline on a nice dish by Brian Selden | 34-45 |
| 16:59 | John Jay | Richard Johnson is whistled for traveling | 34-45 |
| Subs | John Jay | Clifford Lee (PG), Jeff Sears (SG), John Hayes (SF) Richard Johnson, Jerry Goodwin, Joshua Tillett | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Herbert Andrews (PG), Scott Ulrey (SG), Lyman Perry (PF) Robert Hepner, Brian Selden, Robert Sellers | |
| 16:43 | Muskingum | Lyman Perry buries a driving attempt from the right block on a nice dish by Thomas Bateman | 34-47 |
| 16:28 | John Jay | Jeff Sears misses the fadeaway from just outside the lane | 34-47 |
| 16:27 | John Jay | Jeff Sears pulls down the offensive rebound | 34-47 |
| 16:09 | John Jay | Alvin Neace comes up short on the 3 pointer from straight away | 34-47 |
| 16:07 | Muskingum | Lyman Perry gets the rebound | 34-47 |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Clifford Lee (fresh) SG - Jeff Sears (fresh) 4 pts. 3 reb. SF - John Hayes (fresh) 2 reb. PF - Steven Marion (fairly fresh) 7 pts. 3 reb. C - Alvin Neace (fresh) 5 pts. 2 reb. | |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Herbert Andrews (fresh) 6 pts. SG - Scott Ulrey (fresh) 1 pts. 1 ast. SF - Thomas Bateman (fresh) 8 pts. PF - Lyman Perry (fresh) 10 pts. 4 reb. C - William Brunell (fresh) 3 reb. | |
| 15:38 | Muskingum | Lyman Perry comes up short on the fadeaway from the baseline but the foul's on Jeff Sears - foul #2 on Jeff Sears, team foul #2 | 34-47 |
| Subs | John Jay | Richard Johnson (PG), David Heiman (SG), Houston Williams (C) Clifford Lee, Jeff Sears, Steven Marion | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Robert Sellers (SF), Paul Dell (PF), Milton Courville (C) Scott Ulrey, Thomas Bateman, William Brunell | |
| 15:38 | Muskingum | Lyman Perry misses the 1st free throw | 34-47 |
| 15:38 | Muskingum | Lyman Perry misses the 2nd free throw | 34-47 |
| 15:38 | Muskingum | Paul Dell grabs the offensive rebound | 34-47 |
| 15:19 | Muskingum | Robert Sellers makes the shot from the right wing on a great pass from Milton Courville | 34-49 |
| 15:02 | John Jay | Richard Johnson connects on the 3 pointer from the right wing on a nice dish by Alvin Neace | 37-49 |
| 14:41 | Muskingum | Lyman Perry clanks a pull-up jumper from the right wing | 37-49 |
| 14:40 | Muskingum | Milton Courville tips it in | 37-51 |
| 14:23 | John Jay | Richard Johnson comes up short on the 3pt shot from the right wing | 37-51 |
| 14:21 | Muskingum | Milton Courville grabs the board | 37-51 |
| 14:17 | Muskingum | Lyman Perry misses the 3pt shot from the left corner | 37-51 |
| 14:15 | John Jay | Alvin Neace grabs the board | 37-51 |
| 13:51 | John Jay | Houston Williams can't connect on a 3pt shot from the left wing | 37-51 |
| 13:49 | Muskingum | Paul Dell gets the rebound | 37-51 |
| 13:28 | Muskingum | Herbert Andrews loses the dribble to John Hayes | 37-51 |
| 13:25 | John Jay | Alvin Neace misses the easy layup | 37-51 |
| 13:23 | John Jay | Houston Williams tips it back up and in | 39-51 |
| 13:13 | Muskingum | Lyman Perry misses the 3 from the left wing | 39-51 |
| 13:12 | John Jay | Richard Johnson grabs the defensive rebound | 39-51 |
| 13:03 | John Jay | Richard Johnson buries a 3pt attempt from the right wing on a great pass from David Heiman | 42-51 |
| 12:55 | Muskingum | Robert Sellers comes up short on the floater from the right block | 42-51 |
| 12:54 | Muskingum | Lyman Perry tips it but misses | 42-51 |
| 12:53 | John Jay | Richard Johnson pulls down the rebound | 42-51 |
| 12:36 | John Jay | Richard Johnson misses short on a 3 pointer from the left wing | 42-51 |
| 12:35 | John Jay | Houston Williams pulls down the offensive rebound | 42-51 |
| 12:22 | John Jay | John Hayes is whistled for a charge - foul #2 on John Hayes, team foul #3 | 42-51 |
| Subs | John Jay | Clifford Lee (PG), Jerry Goodwin (SG), Joshua Tillett (SF), Steven Marion (PF), Jeff Sears (C) Richard Johnson, David Heiman, John Hayes, Alvin Neace, Houston Williams | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Robert Hepner (PG), Brian Selden (SG), Thomas Bateman (PF), William Brunell (C) Herbert Andrews, Lyman Perry, Paul Dell, Milton Courville | |
| 12:03 | Muskingum | Thomas Bateman's pass is intercepted by Joshua Tillett | 42-51 |
| 12:00 | John Jay | Joshua Tillett banks in the layup | 44-51 |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Clifford Lee (fresh) SG - Jerry Goodwin (fresh) 2 ast. SF - Joshua Tillett (fresh) 6 pts. 2 reb. 2 stl. PF - Steven Marion (fresh) 7 pts. 3 reb. C - Jeff Sears (fresh) 4 pts. 3 reb. | |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Robert Hepner (fresh) 5 pts. SG - Brian Selden (fresh) 4 pts. 5 ast. SF - Robert Sellers (fairly fresh) 9 pts. 3 reb. PF - Thomas Bateman (fresh) 8 pts. C - William Brunell (fresh) 3 reb. | |
| 11:42 | Muskingum | William Brunell lays it in on a great pass from Brian Selden and the foul's on Jeff Sears - foul #3 on Jeff Sears, team foul #4 | 44-53 |
| 11:42 | Muskingum | William Brunell misses the free throw | 44-53 |
| 11:42 | John Jay | Steven Marion gets the rebound | 44-53 |
| 11:20 | John Jay | Thomas Bateman takes the ball from Steven Marion | 44-53 |
| 11:12 | Muskingum | Thomas Bateman misses the lay-in but he's fouled by Jeff Sears - foul #4 on Jeff Sears, team foul #5 | 44-53 |
| Subs | John Jay | David Heiman (SG), Houston Williams (C) Clifford Lee, Jeff Sears | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Paul Dell (PF) Robert Sellers | |
| 11:12 | Muskingum | Thomas Bateman makes the 1st free throw | 44-54 |
| 11:12 | Muskingum | Thomas Bateman makes the 2nd free throw | 44-55 |
| 10:55 | John Jay | Joshua Tillett travels with the ball | 44-55 |
| 10:37 | Muskingum | William Brunell drills a turnaround from the left block on a great pass from Robert Hepner | 44-57 |
| 10:21 | John Jay | David Heiman misses the 3pt shot from straight away | 44-57 |
| 10:20 | Muskingum | William Brunell snags the defensive board | 44-57 |
| 10:15 | Muskingum | David Heiman is called for the reach on Brian Selden - foul #4 on David Heiman, team foul #6 | 44-57 |
| Subs | John Jay | Richard Johnson (PG), Clifford Lee (SG) Jerry Goodwin, David Heiman | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Milton Courville (C) William Brunell | |
| 10:09 | Muskingum | Paul Dell lays it in set up by Milton Courville and the foul's on Houston Williams - foul #1 on Houston Williams, team foul #7 | 44-59 |
| Subs | John Jay | | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Robert Sellers (SF) Thomas Bateman | |
| 10:09 | Muskingum | Paul Dell misses the free throw | 44-59 |
| 10:09 | John Jay | Houston Williams snags the defensive board | 44-59 |
| 09:52 | John Jay | Houston Williams comes up short on the 3pt jumper from straight away | 44-59 |
| 09:50 | Muskingum | Robert Sellers grabs the defensive rebound | 44-59 |
| 09:36 | Muskingum | Paul Dell travels with the ball | 44-59 |
| Subs | John Jay | John Hayes (SF) Joshua Tillett | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Frank Bassett (PG), Scott Ulrey (SG), Lyman Perry (PF) Robert Hepner, Brian Selden, Paul Dell | |
| 09:25 | John Jay | Steven Marion misses long on a floater in the lane | 44-59 |
| 09:24 | Muskingum | Robert Sellers grabs the defensive rebound | 44-59 |
| 09:02 | Muskingum | Frank Bassett scores on a jumper from just outside the lane set up by Scott Ulrey | 44-61 |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a triangle offense (uptempo) and a man to man (+2) | |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a flex offense and a man to man (-1) | |
| 08:44 | John Jay | John Hayes misses short on a 3pt attempt from the right wing | 44-61 |
| 08:43 | Muskingum | The rebound goes to Milton Courville | 44-61 |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a triangle offense (uptempo) and a man to man (+2) | |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a flex offense (slowdown) and a man to man (-1) | |
| 08:28 | Muskingum | Frank Bassett drills a jumper from just outside the lane on a nice dish by Lyman Perry | 44-63 |
| 08:12 | John Jay | Steven Marion's pass is intercepted by Frank Bassett | 44-63 |
| 08:08 | Muskingum | Frank Bassett banks in the layup | 44-65 |
| 07:57 | John Jay | Steven Marion buries a jumpshot from the left wing on a great pass from Richard Johnson | 46-65 |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Richard Johnson (fresh) 17 pts. 3 ast. SG - Clifford Lee (fairly fresh) SF - John Hayes (fresh) 2 reb. PF - Steven Marion (fairly fresh) 9 pts. 4 reb. C - Houston Williams (tiring) 5 pts. 9 reb. | |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Frank Bassett (fresh) 6 pts. SG - Scott Ulrey (fresh) 1 pts. 2 ast. SF - Robert Sellers (fairly fresh) 9 pts. 5 reb. PF - Lyman Perry (fresh) 10 pts. 5 reb. C - Milton Courville (fairly fresh) 8 pts. 5 reb. | |
| 07:28 | Muskingum | John Hayes steals it from Lyman Perry | 46-65 |
| 07:13 | John Jay | John Hayes's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 46-65 |
| Subs | John Jay | Jerry Goodwin (PG), David Heiman (SG), Joshua Tillett (SF), Jeff Sears (PF), Alvin Neace (C) Richard Johnson, Clifford Lee, John Hayes, Steven Marion, Houston Williams | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Robert Hepner (PG), Brian Selden (SG), Thomas Bateman (SF), Paul Dell (PF), William Brunell (C) Frank Bassett, Scott Ulrey, Robert Sellers, Lyman Perry, Milton Courville | |
| 06:57 | Muskingum | Robert Hepner makes the pull-up jumper from the right side set up by Thomas Bateman and the foul's on Jeff Sears - foul #5 on Jeff Sears, team foul #8 | 46-67 |
| Subs | John Jay | Steven Marion (PF) Jeff Sears | |
| Subs | Muskingum | | |
| 06:57 | Muskingum | Robert Hepner misses the free throw | 46-67 |
| 06:57 | John Jay | Steven Marion pulls down the rebound | 46-67 |
| 06:50 | John Jay | Joshua Tillett connects on the floater from the left wing | 48-67 |
| 06:34 | Muskingum | Paul Dell hits the front of the rim on the fadeaway jumper from the free throw line | 48-67 |
| 06:33 | John Jay | Steven Marion grabs the defensive rebound | 48-67 |
| 06:13 | John Jay | Joshua Tillett hits a 3pt shot from the right wing | 51-67 |
| 05:56 | Muskingum | William Brunell loses the dribble to Jerry Goodwin | 51-67 |
| 05:35 | John Jay | Alvin Neace misses badly on a pull-up jumper from just outside the lane | 51-67 |
| 05:34 | Muskingum | The rebound goes to Brian Selden | 51-67 |
| 05:06 | Muskingum | Thomas Bateman makes the jump hook from close range | 51-69 |
| 04:47 | John Jay | Steven Marion misses the easy layup but he's fouled by Paul Dell - foul #2 on Paul Dell, team foul #3 | 51-69 |
| Subs | John Jay | Richard Johnson (PG), John Hayes (SF), Houston Williams (C) Jerry Goodwin, Joshua Tillett, Alvin Neace | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Herbert Andrews (PG), Robert Sellers (SF), Lyman Perry (PF), Milton Courville (C) Robert Hepner, Thomas Bateman, Paul Dell, William Brunell | |
| 04:47 | John Jay | Steven Marion misses the 1st free throw | 51-69 |
| 04:47 | John Jay | Steven Marion makes the 2nd free throw | 52-69 |
| 04:30 | Muskingum | Herbert Andrews is whistled for traveling | 52-69 |
| Subs | John Jay | Clifford Lee (SG), Joshua Tillett (SF) David Heiman, Steven Marion | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Scott Ulrey (SG) Brian Selden | |
| 04:17 | John Jay | Houston Williams is fouled on the floor by Lyman Perry - foul #2 on Lyman Perry, team foul #4 | 52-69 |
| 04:08 | John Jay | Clifford Lee knocks in the fadeaway jumper from the right wing and the foul's on Scott Ulrey - foul #1 on Scott Ulrey, team foul #5 | 54-69 |
| 04:08 | John Jay | Clifford Lee makes the free throw | 55-69 |
| 03:46 | Muskingum | Herbert Andrews misses short on a fadeaway jumper from the left wing | 55-69 |
| 03:44 | Muskingum | Robert Sellers tips it but misses | 55-69 |
| 03:43 | Muskingum | Lyman Perry misses the tip | 55-69 |
| 03:42 | John Jay | The rebound goes to John Hayes | 55-69 |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Richard Johnson (fresh) 17 pts. 3 ast. SG - Clifford Lee (fresh) 3 pts. SF - Joshua Tillett (fairly fresh) 11 pts. 2 reb. 2 stl. PF - John Hayes (fresh) 3 reb. 2 stl. C - Houston Williams (fairly fresh) 5 pts. 9 reb. | |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Herbert Andrews (fresh) 6 pts. SG - Scott Ulrey (fresh) 1 pts. 2 ast. SF - Robert Sellers (fresh) 9 pts. 6 reb. PF - Lyman Perry (fresh) 10 pts. 6 reb. C - Milton Courville (fairly fresh) 8 pts. 5 reb. | |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a triangle offense (uptempo) and a man to man (+2) | |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a flex offense (slowdown) and a man to man (+1) | |
| 03:36 | John Jay | Houston Williams throws it down set up by Clifford Lee | 57-69 |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a triangle offense (uptempo) and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a flex offense (slowdown) and a man to man (+1) | |
| 03:23 | Muskingum | Milton Courville misses badly on a shot from the left side | 57-69 |
| 03:22 | John Jay | Joshua Tillett pulls down the rebound | 57-69 |
| 03:17 | John Jay | Milton Courville takes the ball from Joshua Tillett | 57-69 |
| 02:51 | Muskingum | Herbert Andrews throws a bad pass out of bounds | 57-69 |
| Subs | John Jay | David Heiman (SG), Alvin Neace (C) Clifford Lee, Houston Williams | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Robert Hepner (PG), Brian Selden (SG), Thomas Bateman (SF), Paul Dell (PF) Herbert Andrews, Scott Ulrey, Robert Sellers, Milton Courville | |
| 02:38 | John Jay | David Heiman can't connect on a fadeaway jumper from the right wing | 57-69 |
| 02:37 | Muskingum | The rebound goes to Paul Dell | 57-69 |
| 02:26 | Muskingum | Lyman Perry buries a 3 from the left wing set up by Robert Hepner | 57-72 |
| 02:15 | John Jay | David Heiman comes up short on the 3 pointer from straight away | 57-72 |
| 02:14 | John Jay | Alvin Neace grabs the offensive rebound | 57-72 |
| 02:03 | John Jay | John Hayes clanks a fadeaway from the left side | 57-72 |
| 02:01 | Muskingum | Thomas Bateman gets the rebound | 57-72 |
| 01:41 | Muskingum | Lyman Perry misses badly on a jumper from the right side | 57-72 |
| 01:39 | Muskingum | The offensive rebound goes to Paul Dell | 57-72 |
| 01:28 | Muskingum | Joshua Tillett is called for the reach on Robert Hepner - foul #1 on Joshua Tillett, team foul #9 | 57-72 |
| Subs | John Jay | Clifford Lee (PG), Jerry Goodwin (SG), Steven Marion (PF) Richard Johnson, David Heiman, Joshua Tillett | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Scott Ulrey (SG), William Brunell (C) Brian Selden, Paul Dell | |
| 01:28 | Muskingum | Robert Hepner makes the 1st free throw | 57-73 |
| 01:28 | Muskingum | Robert Hepner makes the 2nd free throw | 57-74 |
| 01:17 | John Jay | John Hayes drills a jump hook from the baseline | 59-74 |
| 00:52 | Muskingum | Thomas Bateman hits the front of the rim on the 3pt jumper from straight away | 59-74 |
| 00:50 | Muskingum | Lyman Perry pulls down the offensive rebound | 59-74 |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a triangle offense (uptempo) and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (+1) | |
| 00:26 | Muskingum | Thomas Bateman clanks a fadeaway from the right side but he's hacked by John Hayes - foul #3 on John Hayes, team foul #10 | 59-74 |
| Subs | John Jay | | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Herbert Andrews (PG) Robert Hepner | |
| 00:26 | Muskingum | Thomas Bateman makes the 1st free throw | 59-75 |
| 00:26 | Muskingum | Thomas Bateman makes the 2nd free throw | 59-76 |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (+1) | |
| 00:22 | John Jay | Jerry Goodwin hits a fadeaway jumper from the left side and he's hacked by Lyman Perry - foul #3 on Lyman Perry, team foul #6 | 61-76 |
| 00:22 | John Jay | Jerry Goodwin makes the free throw | 62-76 |
| 00:00 | Muskingum | Herbert Andrews runs out the clock | 62-76 |