| Lineup | Colgate | PG - Herbert Thompson (fresh) SG - Frederic Prewett (fresh) 9 pts. 2 ast. SF - John Campbell (fresh) 3 pts. PF - Lester McAll (fresh) 4 pts. 5 reb. C - Cody Amico (fresh) 2 pts. | |
| Lineup | Butler | PG - Curtis Wilcox (fresh) 3 pts. 2 ast. SG - Frances Heimann (fresh) 5 pts. 2 ast. SF - Rudy Salisbury (fresh) 8 pts. 4 reb. PF - Ronald Smith (fresh) 9 pts. C - Norman Powell (fresh) 7 pts. 4 reb. | |
| 20:00 | Colgate | John Campbell inbounds the ball | 37-39 |
| Game Plan | Colgate | Colgate is playing a motion offense and a man to man (0) | |
| Game Plan | Butler | Butler is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (+2) | |
| 19:41 | Colgate | Lester McAll makes the runner from the left block on a nice dish by Herbert Thompson | 39-39 |
| 19:16 | Butler | Rudy Salisbury misses short on a fadeaway from the baseline | 39-39 |
| 19:15 | Colgate | Lester McAll pulls down the rebound | 39-39 |
| 18:58 | Colgate | Cody Amico is fouled on the floor by Ronald Smith - foul #2 on Ronald Smith, team foul #1 | 39-39 |
| 18:53 | Colgate | Cody Amico hits the finger roll on a nice dish by John Campbell and he's fouled by Norman Powell - foul #2 on Norman Powell, team foul #2 | 41-39 |
| 18:53 | Colgate | Cody Amico makes the free throw | 42-39 |
| 18:38 | Butler | Frances Heimann makes the 3pt jumper from the left wing on a great pass from Ronald Smith | 42-42 |
| 18:18 | Colgate | Herbert Thompson connects on the 3 from straight away | 45-42 |
| 17:51 | Butler | Ronald Smith misses badly on a jumper from the left side but he's hacked by John Campbell - foul #3 on John Campbell, team foul #1 | 45-42 |
| Subs | Colgate | Javier Arroyo (PG), Chase Smith (SG), Stacy Williams (SF), David Sanches (C) Herbert Thompson, Frederic Prewett, John Campbell, Cody Amico | |
| Subs | Butler | Alan Butler (PG) Curtis Wilcox | |
| 17:51 | Butler | Ronald Smith makes the 1st free throw | 45-43 |
| 17:51 | Butler | Ronald Smith makes the 2nd free throw | 45-44 |
| 17:27 | Colgate | Chase Smith comes up short on the jumper from the right wing | 45-44 |
| 17:25 | Colgate | Stacy Williams gets the offensive rebound | 45-44 |
| 17:06 | Colgate | Stacy Williams throws a bad pass out of bounds | 45-44 |
| Subs | Colgate | Roger French (C) Lester McAll | |
| Subs | Butler | Phillip Gibby (SG), Bernard Montgomery (SF), Kyle Taylor (PF), Christopher Scott (C) Frances Heimann, Rudy Salisbury, Ronald Smith, Norman Powell | |
| 16:52 | Butler | David Sanches is called for the reach on Phillip Gibby - foul #1 on David Sanches, team foul #2 | 45-44 |
| Subs | Colgate | Cody Amico (C) Roger French | |
| Subs | Butler | | |
| 16:37 | Butler | Alan Butler misses badly on a 3 from the left wing | 45-44 |
| 16:35 | Colgate | Stacy Williams grabs the board | 45-44 |
| 16:29 | Colgate | Javier Arroyo can't connect on a jumper from the free throw line | 45-44 |
| 16:28 | Butler | Phillip Gibby pulls down the rebound | 45-44 |
| 16:22 | Butler | Kyle Taylor misses long on a floater from the left wing but he's fouled by Cody Amico - foul #3 on Cody Amico, team foul #3 | 45-44 |
| Subs | Colgate | Herbert Thompson (PG), Frederic Prewett (SG) Chase Smith, Cody Amico | |
| Subs | Butler | Curtis Wilcox (PG) Phillip Gibby | |
| 16:22 | Butler | Kyle Taylor makes the 1st free throw | 45-45 |
| 16:22 | Butler | Kyle Taylor makes the 2nd free throw | 45-46 |
| 16:06 | Colgate | David Sanches blows the layup | 45-46 |
| 16:05 | Colgate | David Sanches grabs the offensive board | 45-46 |
| 15:55 | Colgate | Herbert Thompson can't connect on a jumper from just outside the lane | 45-46 |
| 15:54 | Butler | The rebound goes to Alan Butler | 45-46 |
| Lineup | Colgate | PG - Herbert Thompson (fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. SG - Frederic Prewett (fresh) 9 pts. 2 ast. SF - Javier Arroyo (fresh) 3 ast. PF - Stacy Williams (fresh) 9 pts. 6 reb. C - David Sanches (fresh) 4 reb. | |
| Lineup | Butler | PG - Curtis Wilcox (fresh) 3 pts. 2 ast. SG - Alan Butler (fresh) 1 ast. SF - Bernard Montgomery (fresh) 6 pts. 2 ast. PF - Kyle Taylor (fresh) 3 pts. C - Christopher Scott (fresh) 3 reb. | |
| 15:49 | Butler | Christopher Scott is fouled on the floor by David Sanches - foul #2 on David Sanches, team foul #4 | 45-46 |
| Subs | Colgate | John Campbell (SF), Lester McAll (PF), Cody Amico (C) Javier Arroyo, Stacy Williams, David Sanches | |
| Subs | Butler | Frances Heimann (SG), Rudy Salisbury (SF) Alan Butler, Kyle Taylor | |
| 15:32 | Butler | Frances Heimann scores on a 3pt shot from the left wing on a nice dish by Rudy Salisbury | 45-49 |
| 15:13 | Colgate | 3 seconds is called on Herbert Thompson | 45-49 |
| Subs | Colgate | | |
| Subs | Butler | Ronald Smith (PF), Norman Powell (C) Christopher Scott, Bernard Montgomery | |
| 14:47 | Butler | Curtis Wilcox hits the front of the rim on the shot from close range but he's fouled by Herbert Thompson - foul #2 on Herbert Thompson, team foul #5 | 45-49 |
| Subs | Colgate | Javier Arroyo (PG) Herbert Thompson | |
| Subs | Butler | | |
| 14:47 | Butler | Curtis Wilcox makes the 1st free throw | 45-50 |
| 14:47 | Butler | Curtis Wilcox makes the 2nd free throw | 45-51 |
| 14:26 | Colgate | John Campbell misses short on a shot from the right wing | 45-51 |
| 14:25 | Butler | Norman Powell pulls down the rebound | 45-51 |
| 14:23 | Butler | Javier Arroyo picks off the pass by Curtis Wilcox in the backcourt | 45-51 |
| 14:09 | Colgate | Frederic Prewett hits the front of the rim on the 3pt shot from the right corner | 45-51 |
| 14:07 | Butler | The rebound goes to Norman Powell | 45-51 |
| 13:46 | Butler | Ronald Smith blows the dunk | 45-51 |
| 13:45 | Colgate | Lester McAll grabs the board | 45-51 |
| 13:20 | Colgate | Javier Arroyo connects on the floater from just outside the lane on a nice dish by Lester McAll and the foul's on Curtis Wilcox - foul #1 on Curtis Wilcox, team foul #3 | 47-51 |
| Subs | Colgate | Herbert Thompson (PG), Stacy Williams (SF), David Sanches (PF), Roger French (C) Frederic Prewett, John Campbell, Lester McAll, Cody Amico | |
| Subs | Butler | Alan Butler (PG), Phillip Gibby (SG), Bernard Montgomery (SF), Kyle Taylor (PF), Christopher Scott (C) Curtis Wilcox, Frances Heimann, Rudy Salisbury, Ronald Smith, Norman Powell | |
| 13:20 | Colgate | Javier Arroyo makes the free throw | 48-51 |
| 13:00 | Butler | Bernard Montgomery is fouled on the floor by Stacy Williams - foul #2 on Stacy Williams, team foul #6 | 48-51 |
| 12:35 | Butler | Bernard Montgomery hits a turnaround from close range set up by Christopher Scott | 48-53 |
| 12:06 | Colgate | David Sanches is whistled for a carry | 48-53 |
| Subs | Colgate | Chase Smith (SG), John Campbell (SF), Lester McAll (PF) Javier Arroyo, David Sanches, Roger French | |
| Subs | Butler | Frances Heimann (SG), Norman Powell (C) Phillip Gibby, Kyle Taylor | |
| 11:58 | Butler | Frances Heimann connects on the 3pt attempt from the left corner set up by Bernard Montgomery | 48-56 |
| Lineup | Colgate | PG - Herbert Thompson (fairly fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. SG - Chase Smith (fresh) 6 pts. SF - John Campbell (fresh) 3 pts. 3 pf. PF - Lester McAll (fresh) 6 pts. 7 reb. C - Stacy Williams (fresh) 9 pts. 6 reb. | |
| Lineup | Butler | PG - Alan Butler (fresh) 1 ast. SG - Frances Heimann (fresh) 14 pts. 2 ast. SF - Bernard Montgomery (fresh) 8 pts. 3 ast. PF - Christopher Scott (fresh) 3 reb. C - Norman Powell (fresh) 7 pts. 6 reb. | |
| 11:38 | Colgate | Christopher Scott takes the ball from John Campbell | 48-56 |
| 11:31 | Butler | Bernard Montgomery double dribbles | 48-56 |
| Subs | Colgate | Frederic Prewett (SG) Herbert Thompson | |
| Subs | Butler | Rudy Salisbury (SF), Ronald Smith (PF) Bernard Montgomery, Christopher Scott | |
| 11:04 | Colgate | John Campbell misses the 3pt attempt from the left wing | 48-56 |
| 11:02 | Butler | The rebound goes to Ronald Smith | 48-56 |
| 10:56 | Butler | Alan Butler drills a 3pt shot from the right wing | 48-59 |
| 10:40 | Colgate | Frederic Prewett misses badly on a 3 pointer from the left corner | 48-59 |
| 10:38 | Butler | The rebound goes to Rudy Salisbury | 48-59 |
| 10:11 | Butler | Ronald Smith loses the dribble to Lester McAll | 48-59 |
| 09:56 | Colgate | Lester McAll hits the front of the rim on the floater from the left side | 48-59 |
| 09:54 | Colgate | The offensive rebound goes to Lester McAll | 48-59 |
| 09:38 | Colgate | Chase Smith clanks a 3pt jumper from the left wing | 48-59 |
| 09:37 | Butler | Norman Powell grabs the board | 48-59 |
| 09:33 | Butler | Frances Heimann clanks a 3pt jumper from the left corner | 48-59 |
| 09:32 | Colgate | Stacy Williams gets the rebound | 48-59 |
| 09:04 | Colgate | Norman Powell swats the shot by John Campbell | 48-59 |
| 09:03 | Butler | Norman Powell gets the rebound | 48-59 |
| 08:44 | Butler | Alan Butler misses badly on a jumpshot from the left wing but he's hacked by Chase Smith - foul #2 on Chase Smith, team foul #7 | 48-59 |
| Subs | Colgate | Herbert Thompson (PG), Javier Arroyo (SG), David Sanches (PF), Cody Amico (C) Chase Smith, Frederic Prewett, Lester McAll, Stacy Williams | |
| Subs | Butler | Curtis Wilcox (PG), Bernard Montgomery (SF), Kyle Taylor (PF), Christopher Scott (C) Frances Heimann, Rudy Salisbury, Ronald Smith, Norman Powell | |
| 08:44 | Butler | Alan Butler makes the 1st free throw | 48-60 |
| 08:44 | Butler | Alan Butler makes the 2nd free throw | 48-61 |
| 08:30 | Colgate | Kyle Taylor takes the ball from Herbert Thompson | 48-61 |
| 08:15 | Butler | Alan Butler knocks in the 3pt attempt from the right wing on a great pass from Curtis Wilcox | 48-64 |
| Game Plan | Colgate | Colgate is playing a motion offense (uptempo) and a man to man (0) | |
| Game Plan | Butler | Butler is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (+2) | |
| 07:56 | Colgate | Javier Arroyo can't connect on a pull-up jumper from the left wing | 48-64 |
| 07:54 | Colgate | Cody Amico hits the follow up shot | 50-64 |
| Lineup | Colgate | PG - Herbert Thompson (fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. SG - Javier Arroyo (fresh) 3 pts. 3 ast. 2 stl. SF - John Campbell (fairly fresh) 3 pts. 3 pf. PF - David Sanches (fresh) 4 reb. C - Cody Amico (fresh) 7 pts. 2 reb. 3 pf. | |
| Lineup | Butler | PG - Curtis Wilcox (fresh) 5 pts. 3 ast. SG - Alan Butler (fairly fresh) 8 pts. 1 ast. SF - Bernard Montgomery (fresh) 8 pts. 3 ast. PF - Kyle Taylor (fresh) 3 pts. C - Christopher Scott (fresh) 3 reb. | |
| 07:32 | Butler | Bernard Montgomery makes the 3 pointer from the left corner on a nice dish by Christopher Scott | 50-67 |
| 07:25 | Colgate | Herbert Thompson clanks a 3pt shot from straight away | 50-67 |
| 07:23 | Butler | Bernard Montgomery grabs the board | 50-67 |
| Game Plan | Colgate | Colgate is playing a motion offense (uptempo) and a man to man (0) | |
| Game Plan | Butler | Butler is playing a triangle offense (slowdown) and a man to man (+2) | |
| 07:01 | Butler | Alan Butler comes up short on the jumper from the left side | 50-67 |
| 07:00 | Butler | Bernard Montgomery grabs the offensive rebound | 50-67 |
| 06:42 | Butler | Alan Butler lays it up and in on a great pass from Kyle Taylor | 50-69 |
| 06:37 | Colgate | Herbert Thompson comes up short on the 3pt attempt from the left corner | 50-69 |
| 06:35 | Butler | Alan Butler grabs the defensive rebound | 50-69 |
| 06:14 | Butler | Bernard Montgomery clanks a 3pt jumper from straight away | 50-69 |
| 06:12 | Colgate | The rebound goes to Cody Amico | 50-69 |
| 05:49 | Colgate | Javier Arroyo misses badly on a jumpshot from the left wing | 50-69 |
| 05:48 | Colgate | David Sanches tips it home | 52-69 |
| 05:48 | Butler | Butler calls a full timeout (2 :30 3 full remaining) | 52-69 |
| Subs | Colgate | Frederic Prewett (SG), Stacy Williams (SF), Lester McAll (PF) Javier Arroyo, John Campbell, David Sanches | |
| Subs | Butler | Frances Heimann (SG), Rudy Salisbury (SF), Ronald Smith (PF), Norman Powell (C) Alan Butler, Bernard Montgomery, Kyle Taylor, Christopher Scott | |
| 05:31 | Butler | Ronald Smith hits a 3 pointer from the right wing | 52-72 |
| 05:17 | Colgate | Frederic Prewett can't throw it down | 52-72 |
| 05:15 | Colgate | Cody Amico hits the follow up shot | 54-72 |
| 04:56 | Butler | Norman Powell makes the runner from close range and the foul's on Cody Amico - foul #4 on Cody Amico, team foul #8 | 54-74 |
| Subs | Colgate | Javier Arroyo (PG), David Sanches (C) Herbert Thompson, Cody Amico | |
| Subs | Butler | Bernard Montgomery (PG) Curtis Wilcox | |
| 04:56 | Butler | Norman Powell makes the free throw | 54-75 |
| 04:33 | Colgate | Stacy Williams connects on the jump hook from the right block set up by Lester McAll | 56-75 |
| 04:08 | Butler | Frances Heimann hits a 3 from the right corner | 56-78 |
| 03:57 | Colgate | Lester McAll knocks in the floater from the right wing set up by Javier Arroyo | 58-78 |
| Game Plan | Colgate | Colgate is playing a motion offense (uptempo) and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | Butler | Butler is playing a triangle offense (slowdown) and a man to man (+2) | |
| 03:32 | Butler | Stacy Williams steals it from Bernard Montgomery | 58-78 |
| Lineup | Colgate | PG - Javier Arroyo (fresh) 3 pts. 4 ast. 2 stl. SG - Frederic Prewett (fresh) 9 pts. 2 ast. SF - Stacy Williams (fresh) 11 pts. 7 reb. PF - Lester McAll (fresh) 8 pts. 8 reb. 2 stl. C - David Sanches (fresh) 2 pts. 5 reb. | |
| Lineup | Butler | PG - Bernard Montgomery (fresh) 11 pts. 3 ast. SG - Frances Heimann (fresh) 17 pts. 2 ast. SF - Rudy Salisbury (fresh) 8 pts. 5 reb. PF - Ronald Smith (fresh) 14 pts. 2 reb. C - Norman Powell (fresh) 10 pts. 8 reb. | |
| Game Plan | Colgate | Colgate is playing a motion offense (uptempo) and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | Butler | Butler is playing a triangle offense (slowdown) and a man to man (+1) | |
| 03:15 | Colgate | Javier Arroyo buries a jumper from the left side on a nice dish by Frederic Prewett | 60-78 |
| 02:51 | Butler | Frances Heimann is hacked by David Sanches - foul #3 on David Sanches, team foul #9 | 60-78 |
| Subs | Colgate | Chase Smith (SG), Gonzalo Rizzo (PF), Roger French (C) Frederic Prewett, Lester McAll, David Sanches | |
| Subs | Butler | Alan Butler (PG), Kyle Taylor (PF), Christopher Scott (C) Rudy Salisbury, Ronald Smith, Norman Powell | |
| 02:51 | Butler | Frances Heimann makes the 1st free throw | 60-79 |
| 02:51 | Butler | Frances Heimann makes the 2nd free throw | 60-80 |
| 02:32 | Colgate | Stacy Williams comes up short on the shot from the right side | 60-80 |
| 02:31 | Colgate | Roger French grabs the offensive board | 60-80 |
| 02:19 | Colgate | Frances Heimann steals it from Roger French | 60-80 |
| 02:15 | Butler | Frances Heimann banks in the layup | 60-82 |
| 01:54 | Colgate | Roger French misses badly on a jump hook from close range | 60-82 |
| 01:53 | Colgate | Stacy Williams grabs the offensive rebound | 60-82 |
| 01:42 | Colgate | Stacy Williams can't connect on a fadeaway from the right wing but he's hacked by Bernard Montgomery - foul #1 on Bernard Montgomery, team foul #4 | 60-82 |
| Subs | Colgate | David Sanches (PF) Gonzalo Rizzo | |
| Subs | Butler | Phillip Gibby (SG) Frances Heimann | |
| 01:42 | Colgate | Stacy Williams misses the 1st free throw | 60-82 |
| 01:42 | Colgate | Stacy Williams misses the 2nd free throw | 60-82 |
| 01:42 | Butler | Christopher Scott grabs the defensive rebound | 60-82 |
| 01:27 | Butler | Bernard Montgomery is whistled for traveling | 60-82 |
| 01:06 | Colgate | Javier Arroyo lays it up and in | 62-82 |
| 00:45 | Butler | Phillip Gibby can't finish the layup | 62-82 |
| 00:44 | Colgate | Javier Arroyo snags the defensive board | 62-82 |
| Game Plan | Colgate | Colgate is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | Butler | Butler is playing a triangle offense (slowdown) and a man to man (+1) | |
| 00:38 | Colgate | Javier Arroyo hits a fadeaway jumper from just outside the lane | 64-82 |
| Game Plan | Colgate | Colgate is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | Butler | Butler is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (+1) | |
| 00:14 | Butler | Alan Butler makes the runner in the paint and the foul's on Roger French - foul #1 on Roger French, team foul #10 | 64-84 |
| 00:14 | Butler | Alan Butler makes the free throw | 64-85 |
| 00:07 | Colgate | David Sanches hits a 3pt shot from straight away set up by Roger French | 67-85 |
| 00:00 | Butler | Alan Butler runs out the clock | 67-85 |