| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Brian Ward (fresh) SG - James Stallcup (fresh) SF - Darrel Morris (fresh) PF - Michael Barr (fresh) C - Timothy Jones (fresh) | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Patrick Justice (fresh) SG - Walter Frost (fresh) SF - John Hoffman (fresh) PF - Sammy Moore (fresh) C - Barton Heist (fresh) | |
| 20:00 | John Carroll | Barton Heist wins the tip | 0-0 |
| Game Plan | Otterbein | Otterbein is playing a fastbreak offense and a fullcourt press (0) | |
| Game Plan | John Carroll | John Carroll is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (+2) | |
| 19:44 | John Carroll | John Hoffman scores on a pull-up jumper from the right side on a great pass from Patrick Justice | 0-2 |
| 19:26 | Otterbein | Michael Barr misses short on a pull-up jumper from the left side | 0-2 |
| 19:25 | John Carroll | Barton Heist grabs the defensive rebound | 0-2 |
| 19:18 | John Carroll | Barton Heist misses long on a fadeaway near the basket | 0-2 |
| 19:17 | John Carroll | Walter Frost can't tip it in | 0-2 |
| 19:15 | Otterbein | Darrel Morris pulls down the rebound | 0-2 |
| 19:06 | Otterbein | Brian Ward can't connect on a shot from the left side | 0-2 |
| 19:04 | John Carroll | Sammy Moore grabs the defensive rebound | 0-2 |
| 18:42 | John Carroll | Barton Heist can't throw it down but he's fouled by Brian Ward - foul #1 on Brian Ward, team foul #1 | 0-2 |
| 18:42 | John Carroll | Barton Heist makes the 1st free throw | 0-3 |
| 18:42 | John Carroll | Barton Heist misses the 2nd free throw | 0-3 |
| 18:42 | Otterbein | Timothy Jones grabs the defensive rebound | 0-3 |
| 18:31 | Otterbein | Michael Barr buries a jump hook from close range set up by Brian Ward and he's hacked by Barton Heist - foul #1 on Barton Heist, team foul #1 | 2-3 |
| 18:31 | Otterbein | Michael Barr makes the free throw | 3-3 |
| 18:15 | John Carroll | Walter Frost comes up short on the shot from the right side | 3-3 |
| 18:13 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Michael Barr | 3-3 |
| 18:09 | Otterbein | Brian Ward misses the 3 pointer from the right corner | 3-3 |
| 18:08 | John Carroll | The rebound goes to Barton Heist | 3-3 |
| 18:05 | John Carroll | Walter Frost is called for a moving pick in the backcourt - foul #1 on Walter Frost, team foul #2 | 3-3 |
| 17:51 | Otterbein | Brian Ward is fouled on the floor by John Hoffman - foul #1 on John Hoffman, team foul #3 | 3-3 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Willie Coyle (PG), Manuel Robinson (SG), Kenneth Kremer (SF), Mike Wright (PF), Jimmy Bryan (C) Brian Ward, James Stallcup, Darrel Morris, Michael Barr, Timothy Jones | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Gregory Grensky (PG), Michael Vosberg (SG), John Bleau (SF), Mark Lanier (PF), Garrett Rice (C) Patrick Justice, Walter Frost, John Hoffman, Sammy Moore, Barton Heist | |
| 17:33 | Otterbein | Kenneth Kremer comes up short on the 3pt shot from the left wing | 3-3 |
| 17:31 | John Carroll | Garrett Rice gets the rebound | 3-3 |
| 17:29 | John Carroll | Gregory Grensky travels in the backcourt | 3-3 |
| 17:13 | Otterbein | Mike Wright travels with the ball | 3-3 |
| 16:49 | John Carroll | Willie Coyle steals the ball from John Bleau | 3-3 |
| 16:45 | Otterbein | Willie Coyle lays it up and in | 5-3 |
| 16:41 | John Carroll | Gregory Grensky is fouled in the backcourt by Willie Coyle - foul #1 on Willie Coyle, team foul #2 | 5-3 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Brian Ward (PG), James Stallcup (SG), Michael Nave (PF), Timothy Jones (C) Willie Coyle, Manuel Robinson, Kenneth Kremer, Jimmy Bryan | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Patrick Justice (PG), Sammy Moore (PF) Michael Vosberg, Garrett Rice | |
| 16:24 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice is fouled on the floor by Brian Ward - foul #2 on Brian Ward, team foul #3 | 5-3 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Manuel Robinson (PG), Darrel Morris (SF) Brian Ward, Mike Wright | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Walter Frost (SG), John Hoffman (SF), Barton Heist (C) Gregory Grensky, John Bleau, Mark Lanier | |
| 16:00 | John Carroll | John Hoffman misses badly on a jumpshot from the left side | 5-3 |
| 15:58 | John Carroll | Sammy Moore gets the offensive rebound | 5-3 |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Manuel Robinson (fairly fresh) SG - James Stallcup (fresh) SF - Darrel Morris (fresh) PF - Michael Nave (fresh) C - Timothy Jones (fresh) | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Patrick Justice (fresh) 1 ast. SG - Walter Frost (fresh) SF - John Hoffman (fresh) 2 pts. PF - Sammy Moore (fresh) 2 reb. C - Barton Heist (fresh) 1 pts. 2 reb. | |
| 15:43 | John Carroll | Sammy Moore is whistled for a carry | 5-3 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Nelson Kort (SG), Michael Barr (PF) James Stallcup, Timothy Jones | |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| 15:22 | Otterbein | Michael Barr can't finish the layup but he's hacked by John Hoffman - foul #2 on John Hoffman, team foul #4 | 5-3 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Kenneth Kremer (PG), Jimmy Bryan (C) Manuel Robinson, Michael Nave | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Gregory Grensky (PG), Michael Vosberg (SF), Mark Lanier (PF), Garrett Rice (C) Patrick Justice, John Hoffman, Sammy Moore, Barton Heist | |
| 15:22 | Otterbein | Michael Barr makes the 1st free throw | 6-3 |
| 15:22 | Otterbein | Michael Barr makes the 2nd free throw | 7-3 |
| 15:06 | John Carroll | Mark Lanier comes up short on the fadeaway from the right side | 7-3 |
| 15:05 | Otterbein | Nelson Kort grabs the defensive rebound | 7-3 |
| 15:00 | Otterbein | Darrel Morris misses long on a 3pt jumper from the left corner | 7-3 |
| 14:58 | Otterbein | Jimmy Bryan tips it home | 9-3 |
| 14:40 | John Carroll | Mark Lanier misses the jumper from just outside the lane | 9-3 |
| 14:39 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Jimmy Bryan | 9-3 |
| 14:34 | Otterbein | Kenneth Kremer throws a bad pass out of bounds | 9-3 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Willie Coyle (PG), James Stallcup (SG), Mike Wright (SF), Timothy Jones (C) Kenneth Kremer, Nelson Kort, Darrel Morris, Jimmy Bryan | |
| Subs | John Carroll | John Bleau (SF), Barton Heist (C) Walter Frost, Garrett Rice | |
| 14:14 | John Carroll | Michael Vosberg comes up short on the jumper in the paint but he's fouled by James Stallcup - foul #1 on James Stallcup, team foul #4 | 9-3 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Patrick Justice (PG), Sammy Moore (PF) Gregory Grensky, Mark Lanier | |
| 14:14 | John Carroll | Michael Vosberg makes the 1st free throw | 9-4 |
| 14:14 | John Carroll | Michael Vosberg makes the 2nd free throw | 9-5 |
| 13:52 | Otterbein | Willie Coyle misses short on a shot from just outside the lane | 9-5 |
| 13:51 | Otterbein | The offensive rebound goes to Willie Coyle | 9-5 |
| 13:39 | Otterbein | James Stallcup blows the layup but he's fouled by Patrick Justice - foul #1 on Patrick Justice, team foul #5 | 9-5 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Michael Nave (C) Timothy Jones | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Walter Frost (SG) Michael Vosberg | |
| 13:39 | Otterbein | James Stallcup makes the 1st free throw | 10-5 |
| 13:39 | Otterbein | James Stallcup makes the 2nd free throw | 11-5 |
| 13:32 | John Carroll | Barton Heist's dunk attempt is rejected by Mike Wright | 11-5 |
| 13:31 | Otterbein | Michael Barr snags the defensive board | 11-5 |
| 13:25 | Otterbein | Walter Frost takes the ball from Michael Barr | 11-5 |
| 13:21 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice lays it up and in on a great pass from Walter Frost | 11-7 |
| 13:06 | Otterbein | Michael Nave misses badly on a 3pt jumper from the right wing | 11-7 |
| 13:04 | Otterbein | Michael Barr grabs the offensive board | 11-7 |
| 12:41 | Otterbein | Willie Coyle can't finish the layup | 11-7 |
| 12:39 | Otterbein | Mike Wright tips it back up and in | 13-7 |
| 12:37 | John Carroll | Willie Coyle is called for the reach on John Bleau in the backcourt - foul #2 on Willie Coyle, team foul #5 | 13-7 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Manuel Robinson (PG), Nelson Kort (SG), Kenneth Kremer (SF), Jimmy Bryan (PF), Timothy Jones (C) Willie Coyle, James Stallcup, Mike Wright, Michael Barr, Michael Nave | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Gregory Grensky (SG), Garrett Rice (SF), Mark Lanier (C) Walter Frost, John Bleau, Barton Heist | |
| 12:20 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice connects on the jumpshot from the left side on a nice dish by Gregory Grensky | 13-9 |
| 12:16 | Otterbein | Patrick Justice steps in front of the Manuel Robinson pass | 13-9 |
| 12:13 | John Carroll | Gregory Grensky slams it home on a nice dish by Patrick Justice | 13-11 |
| 11:45 | Otterbein | Manuel Robinson buries a 3 from the right corner on a nice dish by Nelson Kort | 16-11 |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Manuel Robinson (fairly fresh) 3 pts. SG - Nelson Kort (fresh) 1 ast. SF - Kenneth Kremer (fresh) PF - Jimmy Bryan (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. C - Timothy Jones (fresh) | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Patrick Justice (fairly fresh) 4 pts. 2 ast. SG - Gregory Grensky (fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SF - Garrett Rice (fresh) PF - Sammy Moore (fairly fresh) 2 reb. C - Mark Lanier (fresh) | |
| 11:30 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice buries a jumper from the left side set up by Mark Lanier | 16-13 |
| 11:25 | Otterbein | Kenneth Kremer connects on the runner from the left block and the foul's on Garrett Rice - foul #1 on Garrett Rice, team foul #6 | 18-13 |
| Subs | Otterbein | James Stallcup (SG), Darrel Morris (SF), Mike Wright (PF) Manuel Robinson, Nelson Kort, Jimmy Bryan | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Walter Frost (SG), Michael Vosberg (SF), Barton Heist (C) Patrick Justice, Garrett Rice, Sammy Moore | |
| 11:25 | Otterbein | Kenneth Kremer makes the free throw | 19-13 |
| 11:07 | John Carroll | Mark Lanier misses short on a driving attempt near the basket but the foul's on Mike Wright - foul #1 on Mike Wright, team foul #6 | 19-13 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Manuel Robinson (PG) Kenneth Kremer | |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| 11:07 | John Carroll | Mark Lanier makes the 1st free throw | 19-14 |
| 11:07 | John Carroll | Mark Lanier misses the 2nd free throw | 19-14 |
| 11:07 | Otterbein | Mike Wright gets the rebound | 19-14 |
| 10:41 | Otterbein | Mike Wright misses short on a fadeaway from the left block | 19-14 |
| 10:40 | John Carroll | Mark Lanier snags the defensive board | 19-14 |
| 10:19 | John Carroll | Gregory Grensky is hacked by Manuel Robinson - foul #1 on Manuel Robinson, team foul #7 | 19-14 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Nelson Kort (SG), Michael Barr (PF), Michael Nave (C) James Stallcup, Mike Wright, Timothy Jones | |
| Subs | John Carroll | John Bleau (SF), Sammy Moore (PF) Michael Vosberg, Mark Lanier | |
| 10:19 | John Carroll | Gregory Grensky makes the 1st free throw | 19-15 |
| 10:19 | John Carroll | Gregory Grensky misses the 2nd free throw | 19-15 |
| 10:19 | Otterbein | Darrel Morris snags the defensive board | 19-15 |
| 10:08 | Otterbein | Michael Nave hits the front of the rim on the 3 from the left wing | 19-15 |
| 10:07 | John Carroll | John Bleau pulls down the rebound | 19-15 |
| 09:50 | John Carroll | Barton Heist connects on the runner from the left block | 19-17 |
| 09:44 | Otterbein | Nelson Kort misses the 3 pointer from the left wing | 19-17 |
| 09:43 | Otterbein | Darrel Morris pulls down the offensive rebound | 19-17 |
| 09:22 | Otterbein | Manuel Robinson misses badly on a jumper from just outside the lane | 19-17 |
| 09:21 | John Carroll | Sammy Moore gets the rebound | 19-17 |
| 09:19 | John Carroll | Barton Heist loses the dribble to Michael Nave in the backcourt | 19-17 |
| 09:01 | Otterbein | Walter Frost steps in front of the Darrel Morris pass | 19-17 |
| 08:44 | John Carroll | Walter Frost makes the fadeaway jumper from the left side | 19-19 |
| 08:24 | Otterbein | Manuel Robinson connects on the shot from the left side on a great pass from Michael Nave | 21-19 |
| 08:08 | John Carroll | Sammy Moore drills a shot from the free throw line on a nice dish by Gregory Grensky | 21-21 |
| 07:59 | Otterbein | Walter Frost is called for the reach on Nelson Kort - foul #2 on Walter Frost, team foul #7 | 21-21 |
| Subs | Otterbein | James Stallcup (SG), Kenneth Kremer (SF), Mike Wright (PF), Jimmy Bryan (C) Manuel Robinson, Darrel Morris, Michael Barr, Michael Nave | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Patrick Justice (PG), Michael Vosberg (SG), Mark Lanier (PF), Garrett Rice (C) Gregory Grensky, Walter Frost, Sammy Moore, Barton Heist | |
| 07:59 | Otterbein | Nelson Kort makes the 1st free throw | 22-21 |
| 07:59 | Otterbein | Nelson Kort makes the 2nd free throw | 23-21 |
| 07:54 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice is fouled in the backcourt by James Stallcup - foul #2 on James Stallcup, team foul #8 | 23-21 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Darrel Morris (SF), Timothy Jones (C) Nelson Kort, James Stallcup | |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| 07:54 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice makes the 1st free throw | 23-22 |
| 07:54 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice makes the 2nd free throw | 23-23 |
| 07:42 | Otterbein | Mike Wright clanks a fadeaway in the lane | 23-23 |
| 07:40 | John Carroll | John Bleau grabs the board | 23-23 |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Kenneth Kremer (fresh) 3 pts. SG - Mike Wright (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. SF - Darrel Morris (tiring) 3 reb. PF - Jimmy Bryan (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. C - Timothy Jones (fresh) | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Patrick Justice (fresh) 8 pts. 2 ast. SG - Michael Vosberg (fresh) 2 pts. SF - John Bleau (fairly fresh) 2 reb. PF - Mark Lanier (fresh) 1 pts. C - Garrett Rice (fresh) | |
| 07:17 | John Carroll | Mark Lanier drills a pull-up jumper from the free throw line on a great pass from Garrett Rice and the foul's on Mike Wright - foul #2 on Mike Wright, team foul #9 | 23-25 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Manuel Robinson (SG) Mike Wright | |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| 07:17 | John Carroll | Mark Lanier makes the free throw | 23-26 |
| 06:54 | Otterbein | Kenneth Kremer misses the jumper from the left block but he's fouled by Garrett Rice - foul #2 on Garrett Rice, team foul #8 | 23-26 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Michael Barr (PF) Jimmy Bryan | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Gregory Grensky (SG), Sammy Moore (PF) John Bleau, Garrett Rice | |
| 06:54 | Otterbein | Kenneth Kremer makes the 1st free throw | 24-26 |
| 06:54 | Otterbein | Kenneth Kremer makes the 2nd free throw | 25-26 |
| 06:35 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice hits the front of the rim on the jumpshot from the left side but the foul's on Timothy Jones - foul #1 on Timothy Jones, team foul #10 | 25-26 |
| 06:35 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice makes the 1st free throw | 25-27 |
| 06:35 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice misses the 2nd free throw | 25-27 |
| 06:35 | Otterbein | Michael Barr pulls down the rebound | 25-27 |
| 06:09 | Otterbein | Timothy Jones's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 25-27 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Nelson Kort (SG) Darrel Morris | |
| Subs | John Carroll | John Bleau (SF), Barton Heist (C) Michael Vosberg, Mark Lanier | |
| 05:59 | John Carroll | Barton Heist lays it in set up by John Bleau | 25-29 |
| 05:50 | Otterbein | Timothy Jones misses the floater from close range | 25-29 |
| 05:48 | John Carroll | Gregory Grensky gets the rebound | 25-29 |
| 05:29 | John Carroll | Kenneth Kremer is called for the reach on Barton Heist - foul #1 on Kenneth Kremer, team foul #11 | 25-29 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Darrel Morris (SF), Jimmy Bryan (PF) Manuel Robinson, Michael Barr | |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| 05:29 | John Carroll | Barton Heist makes the 1st free throw | 25-30 |
| 05:29 | John Carroll | Barton Heist makes the 2nd free throw | 25-31 |
| 05:12 | Otterbein | Timothy Jones comes up short on the 3 pointer from the right corner | 25-31 |
| 05:11 | John Carroll | John Bleau gets the rebound | 25-31 |
| 05:07 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice travels with the ball | 25-31 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Michael Vosberg (SG), Mark Lanier (PF) Gregory Grensky, Sammy Moore | |
| 04:47 | Otterbein | The jump hook by Timothy Jones is blocked by Barton Heist | 25-31 |
| 04:45 | Otterbein | Jimmy Bryan gets the offensive rebound | 25-31 |
| 04:30 | Otterbein | Timothy Jones throws a bad pass out of bounds | 25-31 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Manuel Robinson (PG), Michael Nave (SF) Kenneth Kremer, Darrel Morris | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Gregory Grensky (SG) John Bleau | |
| 04:09 | John Carroll | Barton Heist misses long on a driving attempt from the left block | 25-31 |
| 04:08 | John Carroll | Mark Lanier gets the offensive rebound | 25-31 |
| 03:48 | John Carroll | Michael Vosberg blows the layup but he's fouled by Michael Nave - foul #1 on Michael Nave, team foul #12 | 25-31 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Brian Ward (PG), James Stallcup (SG), Mike Wright (SF), Michael Barr (PF) Manuel Robinson, Nelson Kort, Michael Nave, Timothy Jones | |
| Subs | John Carroll | John Hoffman (SF), Sammy Moore (PF), Garrett Rice (C) Gregory Grensky, Mark Lanier, Barton Heist | |
| 03:48 | John Carroll | Michael Vosberg misses the 1st free throw | 25-31 |
| 03:48 | John Carroll | Michael Vosberg makes the 2nd free throw | 25-32 |
| 03:39 | Otterbein | Patrick Justice steals the ball from James Stallcup | 25-32 |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Brian Ward (fresh) 1 ast. SG - James Stallcup (fresh) 2 pts. SF - Mike Wright (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. PF - Michael Barr (tiring) 5 pts. 4 reb. C - Jimmy Bryan (fairly fresh) 2 pts. 3 reb. | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Patrick Justice (tiring) 9 pts. 2 ast. 2 stl. SG - Michael Vosberg (fairly fresh) 3 pts. SF - John Hoffman (fresh) 2 pts. PF - Sammy Moore (fairly fresh) 2 pts. 3 reb. C - Garrett Rice (fresh) | |
| 03:28 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice comes up short on the 3pt attempt from straight away | 25-32 |
| 03:26 | Otterbein | Mike Wright grabs the defensive rebound | 25-32 |
| 03:22 | Otterbein | James Stallcup hits the front of the rim on the jumper from the left side | 25-32 |
| 03:20 | John Carroll | Sammy Moore grabs the board | 25-32 |
| 03:16 | John Carroll | Brian Ward takes the ball from Michael Vosberg in the backcourt | 25-32 |
| 03:04 | Otterbein | James Stallcup makes the 3pt jumper from straight away | 28-32 |
| 03:02 | John Carroll | James Stallcup is called for the reach on Michael Vosberg in the backcourt - foul #3 on James Stallcup, team foul #13 | 28-32 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Darrel Morris (SF), Timothy Jones (C) James Stallcup, Jimmy Bryan | |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| 03:02 | John Carroll | Michael Vosberg misses the 1st free throw | 28-32 |
| 03:02 | John Carroll | Michael Vosberg makes the 2nd free throw | 28-33 |
| 02:47 | Otterbein | Brian Ward hits the front of the rim on the fadeaway jumper from the left wing | 28-33 |
| 02:46 | John Carroll | Sammy Moore snags the defensive board | 28-33 |
| 02:40 | John Carroll | Sammy Moore can't connect on a jump hook near the basket but he's fouled by Timothy Jones - foul #2 on Timothy Jones, team foul #14 | 28-33 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Walter Frost (SG) Michael Vosberg | |
| 02:40 | John Carroll | Sammy Moore makes the 1st free throw | 28-34 |
| 02:40 | John Carroll | Sammy Moore misses the 2nd free throw | 28-34 |
| 02:40 | Otterbein | Timothy Jones grabs the defensive rebound | 28-34 |
| 02:14 | Otterbein | Mike Wright is fouled on the floor by Walter Frost - foul #3 on Walter Frost, team foul #9 | 28-34 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Willie Coyle (PG), Kenneth Kremer (SF) Brian Ward, Darrel Morris | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Gregory Grensky (SG), Mark Lanier (PF), Barton Heist (C) Walter Frost, Sammy Moore, Garrett Rice | |
| 02:14 | Otterbein | Mike Wright misses the 1st free throw | 28-34 |
| 02:14 | John Carroll | Mark Lanier grabs the board | 28-34 |
| 01:45 | John Carroll | John Hoffman clanks a floater from the left block | 28-34 |
| 01:44 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice grabs the offensive board | 28-34 |
| 01:34 | John Carroll | Mark Lanier misses the easy layup | 28-34 |
| 01:32 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Timothy Jones | 28-34 |
| 01:27 | Otterbein | Mark Lanier picks off the pass by Kenneth Kremer | 28-34 |
| 01:25 | John Carroll | Willie Coyle steps in front of the John Hoffman pass in the backcourt | 28-34 |
| 01:24 | Otterbein | Kenneth Kremer banks in the layup set up by Willie Coyle | 30-34 |
| 00:58 | John Carroll | Barton Heist misses long on a jump hook from the right block but he's hacked by Michael Barr - foul #1 on Michael Barr, team foul #15 | 30-34 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Brian Ward (PG), Manuel Robinson (SG), Michael Nave (SF), Jimmy Bryan (C) Willie Coyle, Kenneth Kremer, Michael Barr, Timothy Jones | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Sammy Moore (PF) Mark Lanier | |
| 00:58 | John Carroll | Barton Heist misses the 1st free throw | 30-34 |
| 00:58 | John Carroll | Barton Heist misses the 2nd free throw | 30-34 |
| 00:58 | Otterbein | Mike Wright snags the defensive board | 30-34 |
| 00:50 | Otterbein | Brian Ward misses badly on a shot from the right side but the foul's on Patrick Justice - foul #2 on Patrick Justice, team foul #10 | 30-34 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Mark Lanier (C) Barton Heist | |
| 00:50 | Otterbein | Brian Ward misses the 1st free throw | 30-34 |
| 00:50 | Otterbein | Brian Ward makes the 2nd free throw | 31-34 |
| 00:44 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice is fouled in the backcourt by Manuel Robinson - foul #2 on Manuel Robinson, team foul #16 | 31-34 |
| 00:44 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice misses the 1st free throw | 31-34 |
| 00:44 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice misses the 2nd free throw | 31-34 |
| 00:44 | Otterbein | Mike Wright pulls down the rebound | 31-34 |
| 00:39 | Otterbein | Michael Nave banks in the layup | 33-34 |
| 00:33 | John Carroll | Brian Ward is called for the reach on Patrick Justice in the backcourt - foul #3 on Brian Ward, team foul #17 | 33-34 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Willie Coyle (PG) Brian Ward | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Garrett Rice (C) Mark Lanier | |
| 00:33 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice makes the 1st free throw | 33-35 |
| 00:33 | John Carroll | Patrick Justice misses the 2nd free throw | 33-35 |
| 00:33 | Otterbein | Jimmy Bryan grabs the board | 33-35 |
| 00:13 | Otterbein | Garrett Rice is called for the reach on Willie Coyle - foul #3 on Garrett Rice, team foul #11 | 33-35 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Nelson Kort (SG) Manuel Robinson | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Michael Vosberg (SG), Mark Lanier (C) Patrick Justice, Garrett Rice | |
| 00:13 | Otterbein | Willie Coyle misses the 1st free throw | 33-35 |
| 00:13 | Otterbein | Willie Coyle makes the 2nd free throw | 34-35 |
| 00:03 | John Carroll | John Hoffman misses the floater from the right block | 34-35 |
| 00:01 | Otterbein | Nelson Kort grabs the board | 34-35 |
| 00:00 | Otterbein | Nelson Kort comes up short on the fullcourt shot | 34-35 |