| Lineup | Catholic | PG - Kevin Castle (fresh) 5 pts. 3 ast. SG - George Wolfe (fresh) SF - Jesse Peter (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. PF - Edgar Heal (fresh) 8 pts. 2 reb. C - James Smith (fresh) 2 reb. | |
| Lineup | Staten Island | PG - Henry Collins (fresh) 1 ast. SG - James Paul (fresh) 5 pts. 3 ast. SF - Tommy Galloway (fresh) 8 pts. 3 reb. PF - Thomas Mitchell (fresh) 8 pts. C - William Forst (fresh) 2 pts. | |
| 20:00 | Catholic | Jesse Peter inbounds the ball | 39-38 |
| Game Plan | Catholic | Catholic is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (-2) | |
| Game Plan | Staten Island | Staten Island is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (+1) | |
| 19:45 | Catholic | Jesse Peter scores on a fadeaway jumper from the left side set up by Kevin Castle | 41-38 |
| 19:25 | Staten Island | Henry Collins's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 41-38 |
| 19:02 | Catholic | Kevin Castle is called for a pushoff foul - foul #3 on Kevin Castle, team foul #1 | 41-38 |
| Subs | Catholic | Jeremy Strother (PG) Kevin Castle | |
| Subs | Staten Island | | |
| 18:41 | Staten Island | James Smith denies the turnaround by Thomas Mitchell | 41-38 |
| 18:39 | Staten Island | William Forst tips it but misses | 41-38 |
| 18:38 | Staten Island | William Forst snags the offensive board | 41-38 |
| 18:23 | Staten Island | Thomas Mitchell hits the finger roll | 41-40 |
| 18:14 | Catholic | James Smith is hacked by James Paul - foul #1 on James Paul, team foul #1 | 41-40 |
| 18:04 | Catholic | James Smith scores on a fadeaway in the lane set up by George Wolfe | 43-40 |
| 17:44 | Staten Island | Henry Collins makes the jumpshot from the left side | 43-42 |
| 17:24 | Catholic | James Smith drills a 3pt jumper from the left corner set up by Jeremy Strother | 46-42 |
| 17:04 | Staten Island | William Forst misses the 3 from the right corner | 46-42 |
| 17:03 | Catholic | Jeremy Strother gets the rebound | 46-42 |
| 16:49 | Catholic | Edgar Heal blows the layup | 46-42 |
| 16:47 | Staten Island | William Forst snags the defensive board | 46-42 |
| 16:31 | Staten Island | Henry Collins misses the fadeaway jumper from the right wing | 46-42 |
| 16:30 | Staten Island | William Forst grabs the offensive board | 46-42 |
| 16:20 | Staten Island | Jeremy Strother takes the ball from William Forst | 46-42 |
| 16:01 | Catholic | William Forst denies the turnaround by James Smith | 46-42 |
| 16:00 | Staten Island | William Forst pulls down the rebound | 46-42 |
| Lineup | Catholic | PG - Jeremy Strother (fairly fresh) 1 ast. SG - George Wolfe (fairly fresh) 1 ast. SF - Jesse Peter (fairly fresh) 4 pts. 2 reb. PF - Edgar Heal (fairly fresh) 8 pts. 2 reb. C - James Smith (fairly fresh) 5 pts. 2 reb. | |
| Lineup | Staten Island | PG - Henry Collins (fairly fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SG - James Paul (fairly fresh) 5 pts. 3 ast. SF - Tommy Galloway (fairly fresh) 8 pts. 3 reb. PF - Thomas Mitchell (fairly fresh) 10 pts. C - William Forst (fairly fresh) 2 pts. 6 reb. | |
| 15:50 | Staten Island | Thomas Mitchell knocks in the shot from the left block | 46-44 |
| 15:32 | Catholic | Jesse Peter buries a 3 pointer from the left corner set up by George Wolfe | 49-44 |
| 15:20 | Staten Island | Tommy Galloway knocks in the floater from the right block and the foul's on George Wolfe - foul #3 on George Wolfe, team foul #2 | 49-46 |
| Subs | Catholic | Kevin Castle (PG), Jeffrey Hardy (SG), Garfield Ratliff (SF), Lester Owens (PF), Christopher Borger (C) Jeremy Strother, George Wolfe, Jesse Peter, Edgar Heal, James Smith | |
| Subs | Staten Island | Nick Lawhon (PG), Paul Powell (SG), Fred Witter (PF), Albert Mailloux (C) Henry Collins, James Paul, Thomas Mitchell, William Forst | |
| 15:20 | Staten Island | Tommy Galloway makes the free throw | 49-47 |
| 15:07 | Catholic | Jeffrey Hardy is hacked by Paul Powell - foul #1 on Paul Powell, team foul #2 | 49-47 |
| Subs | Catholic | | |
| Subs | Staten Island | Lester Manus (PG) Tommy Galloway | |
| 14:49 | Catholic | Lester Manus takes the ball from Garfield Ratliff | 49-47 |
| 14:42 | Staten Island | Lester Manus misses the pull-up jumper from the right side | 49-47 |
| 14:41 | Catholic | The rebound goes to Lester Owens | 49-47 |
| 14:22 | Catholic | Lester Owens is hacked by Albert Mailloux - foul #2 on Albert Mailloux, team foul #3 | 49-47 |
| 14:15 | Catholic | Christopher Borger misses the 3pt shot from straight away | 49-47 |
| 14:13 | Staten Island | The rebound goes to Paul Powell | 49-47 |
| 14:09 | Staten Island | Lester Manus misses short on a 3pt attempt from the right corner | 49-47 |
| 14:07 | Staten Island | The offensive rebound goes to Paul Powell | 49-47 |
| 13:49 | Staten Island | Albert Mailloux misses long on a driving attempt in the paint but he's fouled by Kevin Castle - foul #4 on Kevin Castle, team foul #3 | 49-47 |
| Subs | Catholic | Walter Favorite (SG) Kevin Castle | |
| Subs | Staten Island | James Paul (SG) Lester Manus | |
| 13:49 | Staten Island | Albert Mailloux misses the 1st free throw | 49-47 |
| 13:49 | Staten Island | Albert Mailloux makes the 2nd free throw | 49-48 |
| 13:31 | Catholic | Garfield Ratliff misses long on a 3 from the left corner | 49-48 |
| 13:30 | Staten Island | Fred Witter gets the rebound | 49-48 |
| 13:08 | Staten Island | James Paul lays it in and he's fouled by Lester Owens - foul #1 on Lester Owens, team foul #4 | 49-50 |
| Subs | Catholic | Edgar Heal (PF), James Smith (C) Lester Owens, Christopher Borger | |
| Subs | Staten Island | Lester Manus (PG) Nick Lawhon | |
| 13:08 | Staten Island | James Paul makes the free throw | 49-51 |
| 12:54 | Catholic | Garfield Ratliff comes up short on the 3 pointer from the left wing | 49-51 |
| 12:53 | Catholic | Walter Favorite tips it in | 51-51 |
| 12:44 | Staten Island | Garfield Ratliff steals the ball from Lester Manus | 51-51 |
| 12:32 | Catholic | James Paul is called for the reach on Walter Favorite - foul #2 on James Paul, team foul #4 | 51-51 |
| Subs | Catholic | Jeremy Strother (PG), Jesse Peter (SF) Jeffrey Hardy, Garfield Ratliff | |
| Subs | Staten Island | Henry Collins (PG), Tommy Galloway (SF), Thomas Mitchell (PF), William Forst (C) Lester Manus, Paul Powell, Fred Witter, Albert Mailloux | |
| 12:27 | Catholic | Jesse Peter clanks a fadeaway from the left side | 51-51 |
| 12:25 | Staten Island | William Forst gets the rebound | 51-51 |
| 12:02 | Staten Island | James Smith is called for the reach on James Paul - foul #1 on James Smith, team foul #5 | 51-51 |
| Subs | Catholic | Lester Owens (PF), Christopher Borger (C) Edgar Heal, James Smith | |
| Subs | Staten Island | | |
| 11:41 | Staten Island | James Paul clanks a 3pt shot from straight away | 51-51 |
| 11:39 | Staten Island | Tommy Galloway tips it back up and in | 51-53 |
| Lineup | Catholic | PG - Jeremy Strother (fresh) 1 ast. SG - Walter Favorite (fresh) 9 pts. SF - Jesse Peter (fresh) 7 pts. 2 reb. PF - Lester Owens (fresh) 1 pts. 3 reb. C - Christopher Borger (fresh) 5 pts. 2 reb. | |
| Lineup | Staten Island | PG - Henry Collins (fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SG - James Paul (fairly fresh) 8 pts. 3 ast. SF - Tommy Galloway (fresh) 13 pts. 4 reb. PF - Thomas Mitchell (fresh) 12 pts. C - William Forst (fairly fresh) 2 pts. 7 reb. | |
| 11:19 | Catholic | Lester Owens drills a fadeaway from close range on a nice dish by Walter Favorite | 53-53 |
| 10:51 | Staten Island | William Forst drills a driving attempt in the lane | 53-55 |
| 10:33 | Catholic | Walter Favorite travels with the ball | 53-55 |
| Subs | Catholic | Jeffrey Hardy (PG), George Wolfe (SG), Garfield Ratliff (SF), Edgar Heal (PF), James Smith (C) Jeremy Strother, Walter Favorite, Jesse Peter, Lester Owens, Christopher Borger | |
| Subs | Staten Island | Nick Lawhon (PG), Paul Powell (SG), Fred Witter (PF), Albert Mailloux (C) Henry Collins, James Paul, Thomas Mitchell, William Forst | |
| 10:14 | Staten Island | Nick Lawhon misses the fadeaway from the left side | 53-55 |
| 10:13 | Catholic | Garfield Ratliff gets the rebound | 53-55 |
| 09:55 | Catholic | Edgar Heal can't throw it down but he's fouled by Paul Powell - foul #2 on Paul Powell, team foul #5 | 53-55 |
| Subs | Catholic | | |
| Subs | Staten Island | Lester Manus (PG) Tommy Galloway | |
| 09:55 | Catholic | Edgar Heal misses the 1st free throw | 53-55 |
| 09:55 | Catholic | Edgar Heal misses the 2nd free throw | 53-55 |
| 09:55 | Catholic | James Smith gets the offensive rebound | 53-55 |
| 09:39 | Catholic | Jeffrey Hardy misses the 3 pointer from the right wing | 53-55 |
| 09:38 | Staten Island | Paul Powell grabs the board | 53-55 |
| 09:30 | Staten Island | Nick Lawhon misses the jumper from the right side | 53-55 |
| 09:28 | Catholic | James Smith snags the defensive board | 53-55 |
| 09:06 | Catholic | Jeffrey Hardy connects on the driving attempt in the lane | 55-55 |
| 08:55 | Staten Island | Lester Manus clanks a fadeaway from close range but he's fouled by Garfield Ratliff - foul #1 on Garfield Ratliff, team foul #6 | 55-55 |
| Subs | Catholic | Jesse Peter (SF), Lester Owens (PF), Christopher Borger (C) Garfield Ratliff, Edgar Heal, James Smith | |
| Subs | Staten Island | James Paul (SG), Thomas Mitchell (PF) Paul Powell, Fred Witter | |
| 08:55 | Staten Island | Lester Manus makes the 1st free throw | 55-56 |
| 08:55 | Staten Island | Lester Manus makes the 2nd free throw | 55-57 |
| 08:45 | Catholic | Christopher Borger is called for a pushoff foul - foul #1 on Christopher Borger, team foul #7 | 55-57 |
| Subs | Catholic | Jeremy Strother (PG) Jeffrey Hardy | |
| Subs | Staten Island | Henry Collins (PG), Tommy Galloway (SF) Lester Manus, Nick Lawhon | |
| 08:25 | Staten Island | Christopher Borger picks off the pass by James Paul | 55-57 |
| 08:01 | Catholic | George Wolfe buries a shot from the left side set up by Jesse Peter | 57-57 |
| 07:44 | Staten Island | Christopher Borger picks off the pass by Henry Collins | 57-57 |
| 07:28 | Catholic | Lester Owens connects on the jump hook from the left block on a great pass from George Wolfe | 59-57 |
| Lineup | Catholic | PG - Jeremy Strother (fresh) 1 ast. SG - George Wolfe (fairly fresh) 2 pts. 3 ast. 3 pf. SF - Jesse Peter (fresh) 7 pts. 2 reb. PF - Lester Owens (fresh) 5 pts. 3 reb. C - Christopher Borger (fresh) 5 pts. 2 reb. 2 stl. | |
| Lineup | Staten Island | PG - Henry Collins (fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SG - James Paul (fresh) 8 pts. 3 ast. SF - Tommy Galloway (fresh) 13 pts. 4 reb. PF - Thomas Mitchell (fresh) 12 pts. C - Albert Mailloux (fairly fresh) 1 pts. 2 reb. | |
| 07:10 | Staten Island | James Paul misses the floater from the left wing | 59-57 |
| 07:08 | Catholic | Christopher Borger gets the rebound | 59-57 |
| 07:02 | Catholic | Christopher Borger makes the 3 from straight away | 62-57 |
| 06:56 | Staten Island | Tommy Galloway's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 62-57 |
| Subs | Catholic | Kevin Castle (PG), Jeffrey Hardy (SG), Garfield Ratliff (SF), Edgar Heal (PF), James Smith (C) Jeremy Strother, George Wolfe, Jesse Peter, Lester Owens, Christopher Borger | |
| Subs | Staten Island | Nick Lawhon (PG), Paul Powell (SF), William Forst (C) Henry Collins, Tommy Galloway, Albert Mailloux | |
| 06:45 | Catholic | James Smith is fouled on the floor by Nick Lawhon - foul #1 on Nick Lawhon, team foul #6 | 62-57 |
| Subs | Catholic | | |
| Subs | Staten Island | Fred Witter (PF) Thomas Mitchell | |
| 06:28 | Catholic | Garfield Ratliff misses badly on a 3 from straight away | 62-57 |
| 06:26 | Staten Island | Nick Lawhon grabs the defensive rebound | 62-57 |
| 06:03 | Staten Island | Paul Powell connects on the jump hook from close range on a great pass from Fred Witter | 62-59 |
| 05:42 | Catholic | Jeffrey Hardy misses short on a 3 pointer from the right wing | 62-59 |
| 05:41 | Staten Island | Nick Lawhon grabs the board | 62-59 |
| 05:29 | Staten Island | Paul Powell knocks in the turnaround in the lane | 62-61 |
| 05:09 | Catholic | Edgar Heal's fadeaway is rejected by Paul Powell | 62-61 |
| 05:07 | Staten Island | William Forst grabs the board | 62-61 |
| 05:01 | Staten Island | Fred Witter misses long on a 3pt attempt from the left corner | 62-61 |
| 04:59 | Catholic | James Smith pulls down the rebound | 62-61 |
| 04:53 | Catholic | Jeffrey Hardy knocks in the 3pt attempt from the left corner on a great pass from Kevin Castle | 65-61 |
| 04:53 | Staten Island | Staten Island calls a full timeout (2 :30 3 full remaining) | 65-61 |
| Subs | Catholic | George Wolfe (SG), Jesse Peter (SF), Lester Owens (C) Jeffrey Hardy, Garfield Ratliff, James Smith | |
| Subs | Staten Island | Henry Collins (PG), Tommy Galloway (SF), Thomas Mitchell (PF) Nick Lawhon, Paul Powell, Fred Witter | |
| 04:36 | Staten Island | James Paul clanks a fadeaway jumper from the right wing | 65-61 |
| 04:34 | Catholic | Lester Owens snags the defensive board | 65-61 |
| 04:23 | Catholic | Kevin Castle misses the 3pt jumper from the right corner | 65-61 |
| 04:21 | Staten Island | Thomas Mitchell gets the rebound | 65-61 |
| 04:07 | Staten Island | Jesse Peter takes the ball from James Paul | 65-61 |
| 03:50 | Catholic | Jesse Peter misses short on a 3pt jumper from the left corner | 65-61 |
| 03:48 | Catholic | George Wolfe can't tip it in | 65-61 |
| 03:47 | Catholic | Lester Owens gets the offensive rebound | 65-61 |
| 03:29 | Catholic | Edgar Heal travels with the ball | 65-61 |
| Subs | Catholic | | |
| Subs | Staten Island | Nick Lawhon (SG) James Paul | |
| Lineup | Catholic | PG - Kevin Castle (fresh) 5 pts. 5 ast. 4 pf. SG - George Wolfe (fresh) 2 pts. 3 ast. 3 pf. SF - Jesse Peter (fresh) 7 pts. 2 reb. PF - Edgar Heal (fresh) 8 pts. 2 reb. C - Lester Owens (fresh) 5 pts. 5 reb. | |
| Lineup | Staten Island | PG - Henry Collins (fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SG - Nick Lawhon (fresh) 4 pts. 1 ast. SF - Tommy Galloway (fresh) 13 pts. 4 reb. PF - Thomas Mitchell (fresh) 12 pts. 2 reb. C - William Forst (fresh) 4 pts. 8 reb. | |
| 03:18 | Staten Island | William Forst makes the jumpshot from the free throw line on a nice dish by Tommy Galloway | 65-63 |
| 02:49 | Catholic | Kevin Castle comes up short on the 3pt shot from the left corner | 65-63 |
| 02:48 | Staten Island | Thomas Mitchell pulls down the rebound | 65-63 |
| 02:30 | Staten Island | Thomas Mitchell throws a bad pass out of bounds | 65-63 |
| Subs | Catholic | Jeremy Strother (SG), Christopher Borger (PF), Garfield Ratliff (C) George Wolfe, Edgar Heal, Lester Owens | |
| Subs | Staten Island | James Paul (SG), Albert Mailloux (C) Henry Collins, William Forst | |
| 02:25 | Catholic | Catholic calls a full timeout (2 :30 3 full remaining) | 65-63 |
| Subs | Catholic | Lester Owens (PF) Garfield Ratliff | |
| Subs | Staten Island | Henry Collins (PG) Nick Lawhon | |
| 02:10 | Catholic | Kevin Castle misses short on a fadeaway jumper from the left side but the foul's on Henry Collins - foul #2 on Henry Collins, team foul #7 | 65-63 |
| Subs | Catholic | George Wolfe (SG), Edgar Heal (PF), James Smith (C) Jeremy Strother, Lester Owens, Christopher Borger | |
| Subs | Staten Island | | |
| 02:10 | Catholic | Kevin Castle makes the 1st free throw | 66-63 |
| 02:10 | Catholic | Kevin Castle makes the 2nd free throw | 67-63 |
| 02:01 | Staten Island | Thomas Mitchell double dribbles | 67-63 |
| 01:32 | Catholic | Kevin Castle is fouled on the floor by Henry Collins - foul #3 on Henry Collins, team foul #8 | 67-63 |
| Subs | Catholic | | |
| Subs | Staten Island | William Forst (C) Albert Mailloux | |
| 01:32 | Catholic | Kevin Castle makes the 1st free throw | 68-63 |
| 01:32 | Catholic | Kevin Castle makes the 2nd free throw | 69-63 |
| 01:25 | Staten Island | Thomas Mitchell misses short on a floater near the basket | 69-63 |
| 01:23 | Catholic | Edgar Heal snags the defensive board | 69-63 |
| 01:11 | Catholic | Tommy Galloway swats the short shot by James Smith | 69-63 |
| 01:09 | Staten Island | William Forst grabs the board | 69-63 |
| 00:54 | Staten Island | Thomas Mitchell is hacked by Edgar Heal - foul #2 on Edgar Heal, team foul #8 | 69-63 |
| 00:54 | Staten Island | Thomas Mitchell makes the 1st free throw | 69-64 |
| 00:54 | Staten Island | Thomas Mitchell misses the 2nd free throw | 69-64 |
| 00:54 | Catholic | Edgar Heal grabs the board | 69-64 |
| Game Plan | Catholic | Catholic is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (-2) | |
| Game Plan | Staten Island | Staten Island is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (+1) | |
| 00:26 | Catholic | Thomas Mitchell is called for the reach on Edgar Heal - foul #3 on Thomas Mitchell, team foul #9 | 69-64 |
| Subs | Catholic | Jeremy Strother (SG) George Wolfe | |
| Subs | Staten Island | | |
| 00:26 | Catholic | Edgar Heal misses the 1st free throw | 69-64 |
| 00:26 | Staten Island | The rebound goes to Tommy Galloway | 69-64 |
| Game Plan | Catholic | Catholic is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (-2) | |
| Game Plan | Staten Island | Staten Island is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and a man to man (+1) | |
| 00:18 | Staten Island | Tommy Galloway knocks in the 3 pointer from the left corner on a great pass from Henry Collins | 69-67 |
| Game Plan | Catholic | Catholic is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (-2) | |
| Game Plan | Staten Island | Staten Island is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and intentionally fouling (+1) | |
| 00:17 | Catholic | Kevin Castle is hacked by Henry Collins in the backcourt - foul #4 on Henry Collins, team foul #10 | 69-67 |
| Subs | Catholic | George Wolfe (SG) Jeremy Strother | |
| Subs | Staten Island | | |
| 00:17 | Catholic | Kevin Castle misses the 1st free throw | 69-67 |
| 00:17 | Catholic | Kevin Castle makes the 2nd free throw | 70-67 |
| Game Plan | Catholic | Catholic is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (-2) | |
| Game Plan | Staten Island | Staten Island is playing a triangle offense and intentionally fouling (+1) | |
| 00:08 | Staten Island | Thomas Mitchell can't connect on a 3pt shot from the right corner | 70-67 |
| 00:06 | Catholic | Edgar Heal snags the defensive board | 70-67 |
| 00:04 | Catholic | Edgar Heal is fouled in the backcourt by Henry Collins - foul #5 on Henry Collins, team foul #11 | 70-67 |
| Subs | Catholic | Jeremy Strother (SG) George Wolfe | |
| Subs | Staten Island | Nick Lawhon (PG) Henry Collins | |
| 00:04 | Catholic | Edgar Heal makes the 1st free throw | 71-67 |
| 00:04 | Catholic | Edgar Heal makes the 2nd free throw | 72-67 |
| Game Plan | Catholic | Catholic is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (-2) | |
| Game Plan | Staten Island | Staten Island is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and intentionally fouling (+1) | |
| 00:00 | Staten Island | Tommy Galloway misses long on a halfcourt shot | 72-67 |