| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Willard Brooks (fresh) 7 pts. SG - Troy Haynes (fresh) SF - Kenneth Pugh (fresh) 4 pts. PF - Bruce Brown (fresh) 4 pts. 4 reb. C - Scott Ojeda (fresh) 3 pts. 5 reb. | |
| Lineup | Sewanee | PG - Carl Walter (fresh) 4 pts. 1 ast. SG - Joseph Glenn (fresh) 7 pts. 1 ast. SF - Steven Borden (fresh) 5 pts. 2 blk. PF - Zachary Roa (fresh) C - Robert Phillips (fresh) 2 pts. 3 reb. | |
| 20:00 | Sewanee | Steven Borden inbounds the ball | 34-25 |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (-2) | |
| Game Plan | Sewanee | Sewanee is playing a fastbreak offense and a man to man (0) | |
| 19:36 | Sewanee | Carl Walter clanks a turnaround near the basket but he's fouled by Willard Brooks - foul #3 on Willard Brooks, team foul #1 | 34-25 |
| Subs | John Jay | Hugo Lewis (SG) Willard Brooks | |
| Subs | Sewanee | | |
| 19:36 | Sewanee | Carl Walter makes the 1st free throw | 34-26 |
| 19:36 | Sewanee | Carl Walter makes the 2nd free throw | 34-27 |
| 19:16 | John Jay | Scott Ojeda comes up short on the turnaround from the right block | 34-27 |
| 19:15 | Sewanee | Joseph Glenn pulls down the rebound | 34-27 |
| 19:11 | Sewanee | Steven Borden drills a 3 from the left wing set up by Joseph Glenn | 34-30 |
| 18:47 | John Jay | Scott Ojeda can't finish the layup | 34-30 |
| 18:45 | John Jay | Troy Haynes tips it back up and in | 36-30 |
| 18:30 | Sewanee | Zachary Roa is denied on a layup by Scott Ojeda | 36-30 |
| 18:29 | Sewanee | The offensive rebound goes to Zachary Roa | 36-30 |
| 18:13 | Sewanee | Robert Phillips drills a 3pt shot from the left corner on a nice dish by Zachary Roa | 36-33 |
| 17:57 | John Jay | Troy Haynes comes up short on the 3pt attempt from the right wing | 36-33 |
| 17:56 | Sewanee | Robert Phillips grabs the defensive rebound | 36-33 |
| 17:54 | Sewanee | Troy Haynes steps in front of the Carl Walter pass in the backcourt | 36-33 |
| 17:36 | John Jay | Scott Ojeda hits a jumper from the left block | 38-33 |
| 17:26 | Sewanee | Joseph Glenn misses badly on a jumpshot from the left side | 38-33 |
| 17:25 | Sewanee | Robert Phillips misses the tip | 38-33 |
| 17:23 | John Jay | The rebound goes to Hugo Lewis | 38-33 |
| 17:11 | John Jay | Hugo Lewis's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 38-33 |
| Subs | John Jay | Gary Ross (PG), Willie Pearce (PF), John McCathern (C) Troy Haynes, Bruce Brown, Scott Ojeda | |
| Subs | Sewanee | Charles King (PG), John Whitley (PF), Steven Crawford (C) Carl Walter, Zachary Roa, Robert Phillips | |
| 16:46 | Sewanee | Joseph Glenn misses short on a driving attempt in the lane | 38-33 |
| 16:44 | John Jay | Hugo Lewis gets the rebound | 38-33 |
| 16:27 | John Jay | John McCathern buries a jumper from the right wing set up by Gary Ross | 40-33 |
| 16:23 | Sewanee | Steven Borden loses the dribble to Gary Ross | 40-33 |
| 16:06 | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh misses the 3pt shot from the left wing | 40-33 |
| 16:04 | Sewanee | Steven Crawford pulls down the rebound | 40-33 |
| 15:58 | Sewanee | Steven Borden hits a runner from the left block set up by Joseph Glenn | 40-35 |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Gary Ross (fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. SG - Hugo Lewis (fairly fresh) 5 pts. 3 reb. SF - Kenneth Pugh (fairly fresh) 4 pts. PF - Willie Pearce (fresh) 2 pts. 4 reb. C - John McCathern (fresh) 2 pts. 3 reb. | |
| Lineup | Sewanee | PG - Charles King (fresh) 1 ast. SG - Joseph Glenn (fairly fresh) 7 pts. 3 ast. SF - Steven Borden (fairly fresh) 10 pts. 2 blk. PF - John Whitley (fresh) 5 pts. 4 reb. C - Steven Crawford (fresh) 2 reb. | |
| 15:43 | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh is whistled for a charge - foul #3 on Kenneth Pugh, team foul #2 | 40-35 |
| Subs | John Jay | Willard Brooks (PG), Chester Stutzman (SG), Troy Haynes (SF), Bruce Brown (PF) Gary Ross, Hugo Lewis, Kenneth Pugh, John McCathern | |
| Subs | Sewanee | Carl Walter (PG), Robert Phillips (C) Joseph Glenn, Steven Borden | |
| 15:18 | Sewanee | Charles King is fouled on the floor by Chester Stutzman - foul #4 on Chester Stutzman, team foul #3 | 40-35 |
| Subs | John Jay | Percy Lee (SF), Scott Ojeda (C) Chester Stutzman, Willie Pearce | |
| Subs | Sewanee | | |
| 15:09 | Sewanee | Carl Walter scores on a floater from the free throw line on a great pass from Charles King | 40-37 |
| 14:53 | John Jay | Scott Ojeda makes the jumper in the paint and he's hacked by Robert Phillips - foul #1 on Robert Phillips, team foul #1 | 42-37 |
| Subs | John Jay | | |
| Subs | Sewanee | Zachary Roa (PF) Steven Crawford | |
| 14:53 | John Jay | Scott Ojeda makes the free throw | 43-37 |
| 14:30 | Sewanee | John Whitley knocks in the floater from the left wing | 43-39 |
| 14:18 | John Jay | Troy Haynes hits a 3 from the right wing on a nice dish by Percy Lee | 46-39 |
| 13:56 | Sewanee | Scott Ojeda is called for the reach on Robert Phillips - foul #3 on Scott Ojeda, team foul #4 | 46-39 |
| Subs | John Jay | Hugo Lewis (SG), Kenneth Pugh (SF) Troy Haynes, Percy Lee | |
| Subs | Sewanee | Joseph Glenn (SG), Steven Borden (SF) Charles King, John Whitley | |
| 13:45 | Sewanee | Joseph Glenn hits a 3pt attempt from the right corner on a great pass from Carl Walter | 46-42 |
| 13:32 | John Jay | Willard Brooks is fouled on the floor by Carl Walter - foul #2 on Carl Walter, team foul #2 | 46-42 |
| Subs | John Jay | Willie Pearce (C) Scott Ojeda | |
| Subs | Sewanee | Timothy Johnson (PF), Paul Choice (C) Zachary Roa, Robert Phillips | |
| 13:20 | John Jay | Willard Brooks misses the jumper from the left side | 46-42 |
| 13:19 | John Jay | The offensive rebound goes to Willie Pearce | 46-42 |
| 13:12 | John Jay | Bruce Brown hits the front of the rim on the jumper from the right wing but he's hacked by Timothy Johnson - foul #1 on Timothy Johnson, team foul #3 | 46-42 |
| Subs | John Jay | Gary Ross (PG) Willard Brooks | |
| Subs | Sewanee | Steven Crawford (C) Carl Walter | |
| 13:12 | John Jay | Bruce Brown misses the 1st free throw | 46-42 |
| 13:12 | John Jay | Bruce Brown misses the 2nd free throw | 46-42 |
| 13:12 | Sewanee | The rebound goes to Joseph Glenn | 46-42 |
| 12:51 | Sewanee | Steven Borden drills a fadeaway jumper from the free throw line | 46-44 |
| 12:42 | John Jay | Paul Choice is called for the reach on Willie Pearce - foul #2 on Paul Choice, team foul #4 | 46-44 |
| Subs | John Jay | John McCathern (C) Bruce Brown | |
| Subs | Sewanee | John Whitley (PF) Timothy Johnson | |
| 12:24 | John Jay | Steven Crawford denies the turnaround by Hugo Lewis | 46-44 |
| 12:23 | Sewanee | Joseph Glenn gets the rebound | 46-44 |
| 12:11 | Sewanee | Steven Borden is fouled on the floor by Gary Ross - foul #1 on Gary Ross, team foul #5 | 46-44 |
| Subs | John Jay | Troy Haynes (SG), Scott Ojeda (C) Hugo Lewis, John McCathern | |
| Subs | Sewanee | Carl Walter (PG), Zachary Roa (PF), Robert Phillips (C) Paul Choice, John Whitley, Steven Crawford | |
| 11:59 | Sewanee | Steven Borden buries a fadeaway jumper from the left side on a nice dish by Carl Walter | 46-46 |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Gary Ross (fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. SG - Troy Haynes (fresh) 5 pts. 2 stl. SF - Kenneth Pugh (fresh) 4 pts. 3 pf. PF - Willie Pearce (fresh) 2 pts. 5 reb. C - Scott Ojeda (fresh) 8 pts. 5 reb. 3 pf. | |
| Lineup | Sewanee | PG - Carl Walter (fresh) 8 pts. 3 ast. SG - Joseph Glenn (fresh) 10 pts. 3 ast. SF - Steven Borden (fresh) 14 pts. 2 blk. PF - Zachary Roa (fresh) C - Robert Phillips (fresh) 5 pts. 5 reb. | |
| 11:37 | John Jay | Troy Haynes hits the front of the rim on the jumpshot from the right wing | 46-46 |
| 11:36 | Sewanee | Carl Walter pulls down the rebound | 46-46 |
| 11:31 | Sewanee | Scott Ojeda steps in front of the Carl Walter pass | 46-46 |
| 11:16 | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh comes up short on the jumper from the right block but he's hacked by Joseph Glenn - foul #3 on Joseph Glenn, team foul #5 | 46-46 |
| Subs | John Jay | Willard Brooks (PG), Bruce Brown (PF) Gary Ross, Willie Pearce | |
| Subs | Sewanee | Charles King (SG), John Whitley (SF) Joseph Glenn, Steven Borden | |
| 11:16 | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh misses the 1st free throw | 46-46 |
| 11:16 | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh makes the 2nd free throw | 47-46 |
| 11:07 | Sewanee | Bruce Brown blocks the short jumper by John Whitley | 47-46 |
| 11:06 | John Jay | Troy Haynes grabs the defensive rebound | 47-46 |
| 11:01 | John Jay | The jump hook by Bruce Brown is blocked by John Whitley | 47-46 |
| 11:00 | Sewanee | Robert Phillips pulls down the rebound | 47-46 |
| 10:54 | Sewanee | The jumper by Charles King is denied by Kenneth Pugh | 47-46 |
| 10:52 | John Jay | Scott Ojeda pulls down the rebound | 47-46 |
| 10:39 | John Jay | John Whitley steals it from Troy Haynes | 47-46 |
| 10:35 | Sewanee | Carl Walter knocks in the runner from close range on a nice dish by Zachary Roa | 47-48 |
| 10:19 | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh connects on the jumpshot from the left wing | 49-48 |
| 09:52 | Sewanee | Carl Walter misses long on a floater from the right side | 49-48 |
| 09:51 | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh gets the rebound | 49-48 |
| 09:31 | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh can't finish the layup | 49-48 |
| 09:30 | John Jay | The offensive rebound goes to Kenneth Pugh | 49-48 |
| 09:03 | John Jay | Troy Haynes hits the front of the rim on the 3 pointer from the right wing | 49-48 |
| 09:01 | Sewanee | Robert Phillips pulls down the rebound | 49-48 |
| 08:39 | Sewanee | Bruce Brown is called for the reach on Zachary Roa - foul #1 on Bruce Brown, team foul #6 | 49-48 |
| Subs | John Jay | Gary Ross (PG), Hugo Lewis (SG), Percy Lee (SF), Willie Pearce (PF), John McCathern (C) Willard Brooks, Troy Haynes, Kenneth Pugh, Bruce Brown, Scott Ojeda | |
| Subs | Sewanee | Paul Choice (PG), Joseph Glenn (SG), Steven Borden (SF), Steven Crawford (C) Carl Walter, Charles King, Zachary Roa, Robert Phillips | |
| 08:32 | Sewanee | Steven Crawford buries a shot from the right wing on a nice dish by John Whitley | 49-50 |
| 08:20 | John Jay | Gary Ross hits the front of the rim on the jumper near the basket | 49-50 |
| 08:19 | John Jay | Willie Pearce hits the follow up shot | 51-50 |
| 08:11 | Sewanee | John Whitley buries a fadeaway in the paint on a great pass from Joseph Glenn | 51-52 |
| 07:56 | John Jay | Hugo Lewis's pass is intercepted by Paul Choice | 51-52 |
| 07:40 | Sewanee | Willie Pearce is called for the reach on Steven Borden - foul #1 on Willie Pearce, team foul #7 | 51-52 |
| Subs | John Jay | Chester Stutzman (SG) Hugo Lewis | |
| Subs | Sewanee | Timothy Johnson (PF) John Whitley | |
| 07:40 | Sewanee | Steven Borden misses the 1st free throw | 51-52 |
| 07:40 | John Jay | Percy Lee grabs the defensive rebound | 51-52 |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Gary Ross (fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. SG - Chester Stutzman (fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. 4 pf. SF - Percy Lee (fresh) 3 reb. PF - Willie Pearce (fresh) 4 pts. 6 reb. C - John McCathern (fresh) 2 pts. 3 reb. | |
| Lineup | Sewanee | PG - Paul Choice (fresh) 2 pts. SG - Joseph Glenn (fresh) 10 pts. 4 ast. 3 pf. SF - Steven Borden (fresh) 14 pts. 2 blk. PF - Timothy Johnson (fresh) C - Steven Crawford (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. | |
| 07:26 | John Jay | Gary Ross makes the 3 pointer from straight away on a nice dish by Percy Lee | 54-52 |
| 06:57 | Sewanee | Paul Choice makes the fadeaway near the basket set up by Timothy Johnson and the foul's on Gary Ross - foul #2 on Gary Ross, team foul #8 | 54-54 |
| Subs | John Jay | Willard Brooks (PG), Bruce Brown (PF) Gary Ross, John McCathern | |
| Subs | Sewanee | Charles King (PG) Timothy Johnson | |
| 06:57 | Sewanee | Paul Choice makes the free throw | 54-55 |
| 06:43 | John Jay | Chester Stutzman hits a 3 from straight away on a great pass from Percy Lee | 57-55 |
| 06:38 | Sewanee | Joseph Glenn misses the dunk attempt | 57-55 |
| 06:36 | John Jay | Bruce Brown pulls down the rebound | 57-55 |
| 06:32 | John Jay | Chester Stutzman loses the ball out of bounds | 57-55 |
| Subs | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh (SF) Willie Pearce | |
| Subs | Sewanee | Carl Walter (PG), Timothy Johnson (PF), Robert Phillips (C) Charles King, Steven Crawford, Paul Choice | |
| 06:09 | Sewanee | Timothy Johnson clanks a floater from the left wing | 57-55 |
| 06:07 | John Jay | Bruce Brown snags the defensive board | 57-55 |
| 05:48 | John Jay | Chester Stutzman hits the front of the rim on the 3 from the left corner | 57-55 |
| 05:47 | Sewanee | Joseph Glenn grabs the defensive rebound | 57-55 |
| 05:42 | Sewanee | Carl Walter's fadeaway is rejected by Percy Lee | 57-55 |
| 05:41 | John Jay | Bruce Brown pulls down the rebound | 57-55 |
| 05:27 | John Jay | Willard Brooks comes up short on the 3 pointer from the left corner | 57-55 |
| 05:26 | John Jay | Chester Stutzman grabs the offensive board | 57-55 |
| 05:19 | John Jay | Willard Brooks's pass is intercepted by Robert Phillips | 57-55 |
| 05:00 | Sewanee | Carl Walter connects on the jumper from the right block | 57-57 |
| 04:32 | John Jay | Willard Brooks's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 57-57 |
| Subs | John Jay | Gary Ross (PG), Hugo Lewis (SG), Troy Haynes (SF), Willie Pearce (PF), Scott Ojeda (C) Willard Brooks, Chester Stutzman, Kenneth Pugh, Bruce Brown, Percy Lee | |
| Subs | Sewanee | Charles King (PG), Paul Choice (SG), John Whitley (SF), Zachary Roa (PF), Steven Crawford (C) Carl Walter, Joseph Glenn, Steven Borden, Timothy Johnson, Robert Phillips | |
| 04:10 | Sewanee | Zachary Roa drills a driving attempt in the paint set up by Charles King | 57-59 |
| 03:48 | John Jay | Willie Pearce misses the easy layup | 57-59 |
| 03:47 | John Jay | Scott Ojeda pulls down the offensive rebound | 57-59 |
| 03:36 | John Jay | Willie Pearce double dribbles | 57-59 |
| Subs | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh (SF) Gary Ross | |
| Subs | Sewanee | | |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Troy Haynes (fresh) 5 pts. 2 stl. SG - Hugo Lewis (fresh) 5 pts. 3 reb. SF - Kenneth Pugh (fresh) 7 pts. 2 reb. 2 blk. 3 pf. PF - Willie Pearce (fresh) 4 pts. 6 reb. C - Scott Ojeda (fresh) 8 pts. 7 reb. 2 stl. 3 pf. | |
| Lineup | Sewanee | PG - Charles King (fresh) 3 ast. SG - Paul Choice (fresh) 5 pts. SF - John Whitley (fresh) 9 pts. 4 reb. PF - Zachary Roa (fresh) 2 pts. C - Steven Crawford (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. | |
| 03:23 | Sewanee | Zachary Roa hits the front of the rim on the driving attempt from the right block | 57-59 |
| 03:22 | John Jay | Hugo Lewis snags the defensive board | 57-59 |
| 03:01 | John Jay | Scott Ojeda lays it up and in on a great pass from Kenneth Pugh | 59-59 |
| 02:58 | Sewanee | Sewanee calls a full timeout (2 :30 3 full remaining) | 59-59 |
| Subs | John Jay | Willard Brooks (PG), Chester Stutzman (SG), Bruce Brown (PF) Troy Haynes, Hugo Lewis, Willie Pearce | |
| Subs | Sewanee | Carl Walter (PG), Joseph Glenn (SG), Steven Borden (SF), Robert Phillips (C) Charles King, Paul Choice, John Whitley, Steven Crawford | |
| 02:47 | Sewanee | Zachary Roa drills a floater in the lane on a nice dish by Robert Phillips | 59-61 |
| 02:34 | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh lays it up and in on a great pass from Chester Stutzman | 61-61 |
| 02:12 | Sewanee | Carl Walter misses short on a jumpshot from the left wing | 61-61 |
| 02:10 | Sewanee | Joseph Glenn grabs the offensive board | 61-61 |
| 01:46 | Sewanee | Zachary Roa is called for a backcourt violation | 61-61 |
| 01:31 | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh misses the shot in the lane but he's fouled by Zachary Roa - foul #3 on Zachary Roa, team foul #6 | 61-61 |
| 01:31 | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh makes the 1st free throw | 62-61 |
| 01:31 | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh makes the 2nd free throw | 63-61 |
| 01:16 | Sewanee | Carl Walter travels with the ball | 63-61 |
| 00:59 | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh drills a 3pt jumper from straight away | 66-61 |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (-2) | |
| Game Plan | Sewanee | Sewanee is playing a fastbreak offense (uptempo) and a man to man (0) | |
| 00:55 | Sewanee | Carl Walter is hacked by Willard Brooks in the backcourt - foul #4 on Willard Brooks, team foul #9 | 66-61 |
| 00:55 | Sewanee | Carl Walter makes the 1st free throw | 66-62 |
| 00:55 | Sewanee | Carl Walter makes the 2nd free throw | 66-63 |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (-2) | |
| Game Plan | Sewanee | Sewanee is playing a fastbreak offense (uptempo) and a man to man (0) | |
| 00:32 | John Jay | Bruce Brown clanks a jumper near the basket | 66-63 |
| 00:31 | Sewanee | The rebound goes to Steven Borden | 66-63 |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (-2) | |
| Game Plan | Sewanee | Sewanee is playing a fastbreak offense and a man to man (0) | |
| 00:26 | Sewanee | Steven Borden misses the 3 pointer from the left corner | 66-63 |
| 00:24 | John Jay | Scott Ojeda gets the rebound | 66-63 |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (-2) | |
| Game Plan | Sewanee | Sewanee is playing a fastbreak offense and intentionally fouling (0) | |
| 00:21 | John Jay | Scott Ojeda is fouled in the backcourt by Carl Walter - foul #3 on Carl Walter, team foul #7 | 66-63 |
| 00:21 | John Jay | Scott Ojeda misses the 1st free throw | 66-63 |
| 00:21 | Sewanee | The rebound goes to Robert Phillips | 66-63 |
| 00:16 | Sewanee | Joseph Glenn buries a runner in the paint | 66-65 |
| 00:15 | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh is hacked by Carl Walter in the backcourt - foul #4 on Carl Walter, team foul #8 | 66-65 |
| 00:15 | John Jay | Kenneth Pugh misses the 1st free throw | 66-65 |
| 00:15 | Sewanee | Zachary Roa pulls down the rebound | 66-65 |
| 00:01 | Sewanee | Zachary Roa is whistled for a carry | 66-65 |
| 00:00 | John Jay | Willard Brooks runs out the clock | 66-65 |